Bob McAdoo GB QB coach a possible candidate | Page 10 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Bob McAdoo GB QB coach a possible candidate

Why does Philbins time get lumped in with Morano and Cam Cameron? Philbin: 7-9, 8-8, ?

Finheaven logic at its finest.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I thought the "6 years" statement would have indicated where I place most of the blame for our current mediocrity, but apparently not. Let me give you another hint: It's Ireland. You now get 3 guesses to figure out where I place the majority of the blame.

(It's Ireland)

By the way, 7-9 and 8-8 aren't exactly ringing endorsements. :lol:
 
Don't you think (if they were smart) they would already have at least an agreement with someone already before they fired Sherman? My guess is they have already selected someone for OC, and that's why it took so long to hear about the firing. We'll see who is announced very, very soon.
 
Don't you think (if they were smart) they would already have at least an agreement with someone already before they fired Sherman? My guess is they have already selected someone for OC, and that's why it took so long to hear about the firing. We'll see who is announced very, very soon.

Or..... more firings is coming.
 
Don't you think (if they were smart) they would already have at least an agreement with someone already before they fired Sherman? My guess is they have already selected someone for OC, and that's why it took so long to hear about the firing. We'll see who is announced very, very soon.

so you think it was smart of them to pursue Harbaugh, before getting rid of Sparano?
 
Soooo, Joe is going to hire a guy that has NEVER called plays at any level? Wow....

That is as dumb as hiring an OC as a team's head coach even though the guy never called plays as the OC....oops.

I'm sorry this has taken me so long to reply but I knew you toting this argument didn't hold water at all.

I looked up the first 5 OC's that came to mind and none of them had any OC experience before being given their first OC positions. Their names; Darryll Bevell, Gary Kubiak, Josh McDaniels, Greg Roman and Ken Whisenhunt. I stopped after looking up these five. I'm guessing there are many more OC's in the NFL who hadn't had any play calling experience before being given their first OC job. Try a new angle to bash the possible decision.
 
I'm sorry this has taken me so long to reply but I knew you toting this argument didn't hold water at all.

I looked up the first 5 OC's that came to mind and none of them had any OC experience before being given their first OC positions. Their names; Darryll Bevell, Gary Kubiak, Josh McDaniels, Greg Roman and Ken Whisenhunt. I stopped after looking up these five. I'm guessing there are many more OC's in the NFL who hadn't had any play calling experience before being given their first OC job. Try a new angle to bash the possible decision.

Yep. Here's how I look at it:

Does Ben McAdoo know what a quarterback sneak is? If so, he should be an improvement in terms of playcalling.
 
I can't see Philbin being more of a play-caller. He was not the playcaller in GB, and he let Sherman call plays in Miami. If he was ever a play-caller, he would've put his stamp on this Dolphins team the last two years.

Let's face it: Philbin's only accomplishment so far was the process of having both the 1st & second teams practice at the same time and just flip his chair around to watch them (as highlighted in Hard Knocks). That's pretty cool. The fact that he did that, though, and still managed to see how terrible we were on the offensive line is pretty damning.
 
"That has more to do with Dalton being terrible. Dude is already as good as he'll ever be. If anything, the fact that the offense has been that effective with Dalton back there is a credit to Gruden's ability."

You stole my post. Dalton's melt-down is all about what lies in his psyche and how he handles pressure. The play designs and overall flow of the offense are really good. Dalton just doesn't seem to have 'it'. He lacks poise and makes bad plays when he's pushed to the brink.

To some degree, this is why I'd like to see some competition for Tannehill this summer. He makes some of those bonehead plays too that scare me, but then he also makes some miraculous plays. Still, you could see confidence just draining out of him late in that Jets game. When things start to 'snowball' on a QB, it reveals a fragile psyche and we just can't have that and think we're gonna go anywhere. I'll take a guy with lesser physical metrics but more poise anytime. That's 50/50 with a slight + in Tannehill's favor, IMO. He overcame some really bad starts to rally his team quite a few times this season. He started the 2nd half of the Pittsburgh game with a pick-6, then took the team down the field for a TD, then answered yet another Pittsburgh score to give us the winning margin.
I just wanna see our guy compete compete compete, and I want an offensive coordinator that's gonna push RT to do that. No more of this 'running for 20 yards and sliding so that you missed the first down by one yard' BS. Make Tanny compete in practice, and if he chokes vs camp competition then it's an easy decision. The David Garrard injury in 2012 pretty much handed RT17 the job, and there was no competition in 2013 at all. We did start 3-0 so it didn't seem necessary, but our D did have to hold on to leads when the offense failed to ice the game and left the door open.
 
IMO Dalton's problem is that his arm is trash. I haven't seen every single Bengals game but a lot of what I see on Dalton is interceptions on outside breaking routes and balls that hang in the air too long. He's not Chad Pennington or Peyton Manning good with timing, accuracy, etc. to compensate for that.
 
from CK

Chris Kouffman ‏@ckparrot 60s
There's a rule states assistant coaches w/ expiring contracts that go to playoffs still belong to team until the 3rd Tuesday after last game

Green Bay doesn't let their assistants look at coordinating gigs so...
 
from CK

Chris Kouffman ‏@ckparrot 60s
There's a rule states assistant coaches w/ expiring contracts that go to playoffs still belong to team until the 3rd Tuesday after last game

Green Bay doesn't let their assistants look at coordinating gigs so...

They couldn't possibly be that anal about it, though?
 
from CK

Chris Kouffman ‏@ckparrot 60s
There's a rule states assistant coaches w/ expiring contracts that go to playoffs still belong to team until the 3rd Tuesday after last game

Green Bay doesn't let their assistants look at coordinating gigs so...

I thought that assistants could be accessed if the inquiring team asked Green Bay for permission. Which Cleveland requested and received.
 
They couldn't possibly be that anal about it, though?

they are and Tampa used to be just as bad. It's the reason why when Tampa was hiring assistants for Schiano a lot of teams got "revenge" on them.

You can't block a coach from interviewing for a HC gig, but any other gig you can.
 
I'm sorry this has taken me so long to reply but I knew you toting this argument didn't hold water at all.

I looked up the first 5 OC's that came to mind and none of them had any OC experience before being given their first OC positions. Their names; Darryll Bevell, Gary Kubiak, Josh McDaniels, Greg Roman and Ken Whisenhunt. I stopped after looking up these five. I'm guessing there are many more OC's in the NFL who hadn't had any play calling experience before being given their first OC job. Try a new angle to bash the possible decision.

So there might an OC that has never called plays before, a DC that had never made calls before and a HC going into his 3rd year that has never been over .500. Sounds like a good recipe.

All the OC's you researched had strong, powerful HC's within the organization. That is not the case in Miami.

---------- Post added at 01:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:03 PM ----------
 
Back
Top Bottom