Do not resign Tua | Page 5 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Do not resign Tua

Naw keep Tua, he should be nice and cheap now. And keep McDaniel too until we can find something better, shouldn’t take too long
 
DolfanWally said:
Please stop, If you think Tua is the problem and that team would be better without Tua you clearly don't know football. Not sure what you are watching. Maybe you should watch other QBs and read some stats without a biased agenda against Tua. Football is a team sport you need all pieces to function if you want to be successful. Based on your QB evaluation you must also think Marino sucked because he only led the phins to 1 superbowl. Your entitled to you uneducated opinion but please don't jump on the Bandwagon when Tua is successful.
Click to expand...
lol yes, exactly Marino led us to a super bowl. Tua, after this year, will have zero playoff wins despite our owner spending whatever the **** just to get the right guys. Tua does not win big games, how is he supposed to win in the playoffs
 
Let Tua walk and we get to do the last 20+ years over again. Sounds fun. So when do we get Jay Fiedler back to start the misery over?

Nah. You can win with Tua. You can win without having THE very best QB in the NFL. He's not the problem. At the very least he’s a very good QB overall.

You can’t win games when your defense gives up 56 points on the road and your entire coaching staff gets demoralized in all 3 phases. Also throw in being out 7 starters to begin with. This disaster isn’t on the QB. I’m sorry.
 
mandal24 said:
I totally respect that but it kinda shows you the good qbs from the not so good. Ravens were down their entire secondary lol Bills defense has been decimated this year, Mahomes has the worst WR group in the league.. All can win when you need them. Tua needs everything to be perfect
Click to expand...
The Chiefs are 1-3 in their last 4 games. So they didn't need to win any of those games?
 
I’m fine with Tua but I do think McDaniel with a QB who can extend plays would set the league on fire. Hard part is McDaniel loves Tua, Tua is a great kid and perfect face of a franchise because of his class and character. So McDaniel if proven a great coach may not be in Miami when he finds the right pairing. Like Tannehill we’ll probably ride Tua to year 7 or 8 til they decide to move on or not.
 
superphin said:
The narrative is what is Tua with out Hill. Well what was Allen before Diggs? What has Russ done without an elite defense and run game? How many SBs has he won without it? What does owning the Dolphins matter? We suck right? How is owning a sorry team like the Dolphins an impressive feat?
Click to expand...
I already showed you Russ's stats in the Super Bowl. He was awesome. Allen also came from Wyoming. He was raw and needed time. He's an absolute monster and can actually lead his team (despite yes, he is a turnover machine). I'd take Russ and especially Allen over Tua all day.
 
Michael Scott said:
He also had 2 perfectly thrown balls dropped in the endzone by Hill and Claypool. Had 2 TD passes dropped in Philly as well and you guys let him have it after that game.

Again, while not anything close to spectacular — not the reason we lost this game or anything close to it.

McDaniel and Fangio should be the names getting dragged in the mud today. They were both equally terrible.
Click to expand...

Yes, and Miami got a FG after the Hill drop and still scored a TD after the Claypool drop. Both the drops were inconsequential in the end.

Can NOT stress enough that turning the ball over before the half leading to a TD for the other team is the worst kind of sloppy low IQ football. Especially since he hurried to get that play off before the two minute warning. That WAS the turning point.
 
mandal24 said:
Whaaaat? So Tua is just gonna be the guy where coaches go to die.. You want Tua to have a 3rd QB? McDaniel has turned Tua into the 20th ranked QB into a top 10 guy (mostly against bad teams tho)
Click to expand...

Tua has always been the same guy. He’s never needed anyone to turn him into anything.

He needs 3 seconds, not 2.2.

Tua will complete passes to anyone if we given the time.

You really think the motions are what made Tua?
 
Last edited:
Michael Scott said:
Let Tua walk and we get to do the last 20+ years over again. Sounds fun. So when do we get Jay Fiedler back to start the misery over?

Nah. You can win with Tua. You can win without having THE very best QB in the NFL. He's not the problem. At the very least he’s a very good QB overall.
Click to expand...
Lol. People think we just let tua go and then we go on Amazon and order something better.
 
The Ghost said:
Tua has always been the same guy. He’s never needed anyone to turn him into anything.

He needs 3 seconds, not 2.2.

Tua will complete passes to anyone I’d given the time.

You really think the motions are what made Tua?
Click to expand...
How did Tua look pre-McDaniel?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom