Do not resign Tua

[mandal24]

And wtf did Mr irrelevant do in Baltimore last week? 4 friggen picks. Our guys dropped 2 touchdowns. Thats 33 points. 33 isn't enough to win? That's the Tuas fault? Seriously. Dude give the man a ****ing chance. Its not even really his 3rd year as the starter with the **** Flores put him through which woulda crushed any one else mentally. We do not run THE San Fran offense. That offense is 100% run first because of the talent on their team. Best oline in the NFL, best D in the NFL, stud receivers , stud TE , stud RB. ****ing grappalo would have the same record as purdy if not better and he sucks. We the run a much much more nuanced version that is pass first due to our "talent composition " Purdy wouldnt have 5 wins on this team. That's a fact. Pocket passers don't get outside the pocket either they climb it. If Tua broke outside the pocket he'd get murdered because our oline is expecting him to step up into the pocket. Thats not on him that's 100% on McDaniels. Tua can run, he's not slow. There isn't one play in our book with a roll out. **** I've screamed 4 it. It would shock the other team like the 85 bears. What did Dan just roll out wtf....what do we do omg. **** ain't on Tua yall are nuts.

Purdy threw 4 TDs against the Cowboys
4TDs and the Eagles

And **** the bed for the first time this year against the best team in football, correct

 

[mandal24]

You’re a dunce cap. That’s all there is to it.

“Hebert can’t anticipate” lmao

he doesnt throw on anticipation. Tua does that at an elite level. Herbert is actually the opposite type QB then Tua. No anticipation, reads and reacts, extends plays to find the open man.

 

[NBP81]

So Tua is capable of beating premiere teams... Got it.. In what world?

Tua is capable of extending plays with his legs?

Tua is capable of performing a QB sneak?

Tua doesn't go into total freak out mode when the pocket collapses (he did have a ****ing BEAAUTIFUL maneuver in the pocket in his own goal line vs the cowboys when he hit waddle for the bomb.. Major props)

Tua is playing the wrong era. He's a 90s statue-esque QB playing in 2024 when a QBs legs are almost as valuable as his arm

QBs that can take a hit, extend plays, get creative are all traits the great ones in 2024 have - and most, if not all are better than Tua

Mahomes (better)
LJ (better)
Hurts (better)
Allen (better)
Burrow (better)
Herbert (neutral)
Dak (better)
Stroud (better)
Russ (better)
Fields (worse)
Lawrence (neutral)

And yet Tua has outperformed everyone but one of them this season...

 

[mandal24]

Yeah, but we gave up 48, 31 and 56 points in those losses.

With a better defensive effort, we at least have a fighting chance of winning those games based on what our offence could’ve done. It’s crazy to expect your QB to lead your team to score 49, 32 or 57 points on the road to beat those teams. Ain’t happening. Those losses were on the d, not Tua.

You conveniently left out that Tua turned the ball over in each of those games

 

[TheMageGandalf]

Competition breeds success yes. That's not where we need it though. No way I'm spending capital on a qb in the draft when we need so many other positions right now.

I agree... to an extent...as if a qb is there for you to take that you see as good competition and or prospect, you bite ....bpa and that's for any position...

Then again I have ptsd with Grier when it comes to bpa because boy when he misses man he misses bad

 

[OttawaFinsUp]

You conveniently left out that Tua turned the ball over in each of those games

You conveniently left out that QBs turn the ball over all across the league and their defences still don’t give up 48, 31 and 56 points.

 

[Yessir]

he doesnt throw on anticipation. Tua does that at an elite level. Herbert is actually the opposite type QB then Tua. No anticipation, reads and reacts, extends plays to find the open man.

You have zero clue in what you’re talking about. Please stop it.

You couldn’t break down an all-22 if your life depended on it. You’re making embarrassing statements that can easily be disproven by the film.

 

[mandal24]

And yet Tua has outperformed everyone but one of them this season...

Whats happening right now? It's getting a bit delusional at this point

You're the GM of a franchise and you can pick any QB on that list to be your franchise guy...

Surely, you're not taking Tua.Where does Tua rank?

The only QB Tua is realistically better than is Justin Fields.

 

[mandal24]

You conveniently left out that QBs turn the ball over all across the league and their defences still don’t give up 48, 31 and 56 points.

Again, Tua scored 10 points vs the Eagles. 10 points (i forgot, baker had a pick 6)

 

[NBP81]

Whats happening right now? It's getting a bit delusional at this point

You're the GM of a franchise and you can pick any QB on that list to be your franchise guy...

Surely, you're not taking Tua.Where does Tua rank?

The only QB Tua is realistically better than is Justin Fields.

See! again... You present your opinion as fact, and when faced with reality, you move goal posts. Let me ask you this... Do you believe the earth is flat? I'm only asking because you argue like those who do...

 

[OttawaFinsUp]

Whats happening right now? It's getting a bit delusional at this point

You're the GM of a franchise and you can pick any QB on that list to be your franchise guy...

Surely, you're not taking Tua.Where does Tua rank?

The only QB Tua is realistically better than is Justin Fields.

What’s happening right now is that he can literally win a game and secure the 2 seed. That would be a top 4 accomplishment.

 

[RedWhiteNBlue]

Our defense ****ing sucks in big time games. I'm not denying that but Dolphins offense scored 20 points vs the Bills, 17 vs the Eagles, and 19 vs the Ravens. The Ravens game, I will say, did look really encouraging to start... until the inevitable Tua pick at the worst possible moment. It's also, part of his MO sadly.

You can throw the eagles game out that was ****ing horse **** and the entire world knew it. That ref was removed from the NFL permanently after the chiefs/Packers game. He lived 60 miles from the stadium and was caught on the take in the College championship game which he's never allowed to ref again. No call on the PI rip my face mask off b4 the half that woulda been a TD and no call with mostert being dragged to the ground near the end...again that woulda led to another TD or the chance for one. **** that game.
We dropped 2 touchdowns in the ravens game. DROPPED. Thats 33 points. Ah **** it those perfect passes where Tuas fault my bad.
Bills game was kader kohou on Diggs show. Tua threw almost 300 1td 1 pick. Sacked 4 times in under 2 seconds....those sacks were not on him. Not that day. Some days yes. Not that one. Atleast he didn't toss it for picks and took the sacks.
I'm failing to see how these games are Tuas fault.

 

[mandal24]

You have zero clue in what you’re talking about. Please stop it.

You couldn’t break down an all-22 if your life depended on it. You’re making embarrassing statements that can easily be disproven by the film.

k cool. Herbert can't touch Tua's anticipation. Herbert is a dink and dunk guy. He has one of the lowest Air Yards in the nfl. please sit this one out chief

 

[mandal24]

What’s happening right now is that he can literally win a game and secure the 2 seed. That would be a top 4 accomplishment.

And you really think that's going to happen? I mean dead serious. It's not going to happen. Tua would need to throw for 400 yards and 3 TDs

 

[mandal24]

You can throw the eagles game out that was ****ing horse **** and the entire world knew it. That ref was removed from the NFL permanently after the chiefs/Packers game. He lived 60 miles from the stadium and was caught on the take in the College championship game which he's never allowed to ref again. No call on the PI rip my face mask off b4 the half that woulda been a TD and no call with mostert being dragged to the ground near the end...again that woulda led to another TD or the chance for one. **** that game.
We dropped 2 touchdowns in the ravens game. DROPPED. Thats 33 points. Ah **** it those perfect passes where Tuas fault my bad.
Bills game was kader kohou on Diggs show. Tua threw almost 300 1td 1 pick. Sacked 4 times in under 2 seconds....those sacks were not on him. Not that day. Some days yes. Not that one. Atleast he didn't toss it for picks and took the sacks.
I'm failing to see how these games are Tuas fault.

for the love of god, its not 33 points. we kicked a fg on the drive of the dropped TD. smh you're just rambling and making **** up