Haha, Ok. Part III of my "Lists": The Top 10 WORST Miami Dolphins of all Time

[RoKnRuiN]

no way should ricky be on this list.

Wanny #1 and Ricky #1a!

 

[RoKnRuiN]

Excellent post by the way. :woowoo:

 

[Ozzy]

Pathetic List.

Sammy Smith can't be on that list.

He played great in a playoff game which led to a win (KC).

he then played great in a Div. Playoff loss to Buffalo.


A guy that had two very good playoff performances...CANNOT be on this list.



The list is not well thought out at all.

Please tell me this is some kind of joke?

The number 9 pick in the draft is expected to be an impact player right? And a Rb pick in that slot should be expected to reach 1000 yards right? Not once in either catagory.

And those great playoff games consist of 99 yds with no Td's in a loss to Barfalo, and a whopping 82 yds with no Td's in a win against KC.

His fame, is and will always be, for fumbling the ball on a more consistant basis than he ever gained 4 yards in a single carry.

He was a huge bust, and he sure does belong on that list.

 

[DoctorFeelgood]

Worst Dolphins?

H.M. - Nick Saban

H.M. - Kippy Brown

H.M. - Chris Foerster

H.M. - Dave Wannstedt

H.M. - Rick Spielman

H.M. - Tom Olivadatti

10. Eric Green

9. Randall "The Thrill" Hill

8. Sammie Smith

7. Reggie Howard

6. Gene Atkins

5. Michael Stewart

4. Jarvis Williams

3. Vestee Jackson

2. J.B. "Just Burnt" Brown

1. Jay Fielder

Edit: I just realized 6 of my 10 are defensive backs. Jeebus H. Christ, have we had some terrible DBs over the years or what? If it weren't for Madison and Surtain, Jake Scott, and maybe Louis Oliver, I'd be wondering if we'd ever had a decent DB. Oh, and Troy Vincent... too bad we didn't keep him.

 

[Section126]

Please tell me this is some kind of joke?

The number 9 pick in the draft is expected to be an impact player right? And a Rb pick in that slot should be expected to reach 1000 yards right? Not once in either catagory.

And those great playoff games consist of 99 yds with no Td's in a loss to Barfalo, and a whopping 82 yds with no Td's in a win against KC.

His fame, is and will always be, for fumbling the ball on a more consistant basis than he ever gained 4 yards in a single carry.

He was a huge bust, and he sure does belong on that list.

I can tell that you didn't see those games.

He may belong on the list...but nowhere near that high.

 

[Section126]

Worst Dolphins?

H.M. - Nick Saban

H.M. - Kippy Brown

H.M. - Chris Foerster

H.M. - Dave Wannstedt

H.M. - Rick Spielman

H.M. - Tom Olivadatti

10. Eric Green

9. Randall "The Thrill" Hill

8. Sammie Smith

7. Reggie Howard

6. Gene Atkins

5. Michael Stewart

4. Jarvis Williams

3. Vestee Jackson

2. J.B. "Just Burnt" Brown

1. Jay Fielder

Edit: I just realized 6 of my 10 are defensive backs. Jeebus H. Christ, have we had some terrible DBs over the years or what? If it weren't for Madison and Surtain, Jake Scott, and maybe Louis Oliver, I'd be wondering if we'd ever had a decent DB. Oh, and Troy Vincent... too bad we didn't keep him.

jesus H Christ...what games do you guys watch?

JB Brown was an adequet corner.

Jay Fiedler may suck...but he had a good record as the starting QB.

Michael Stewart was a VERY GOOD SS for us.

Ditto on Jarvis Williams.

 

[Section126]

Define "played great"

I've seen you defend this guy before and it amazes me.

A number 9 overall pick that was expected to be a franchise back has 2 enigma performances and that makes a career? Again, the man was 9th overall, expected to be our franchise back to compliment Marino and should have put up regular performances like the couple you mentioned above.

He was one of our biggest draft busts ever without question.

I watched those games.

If a guy contributes anything in the playoffs...you can't put him on this list. Period.

There are hundreds of guys that contributed nothing AND were high draft picks.

Sammy Smith was easily better than Lorenzo Hampton, Cecil Collins, Jerris McPhail and John Avery.

 

[Section126]

Neither playoff performance was earthshattering as you are trying to imply (not like Lamar Smith's 2000 game against the Colts), and I don't see why someone having a few good playoff games in a season that ended early means they "can't be on the list". Look at the dudes career...he belongs here.

What a nonsense post. You didn't even expand on your problems with the list outside of Sammie Smith. Better luck next time (and I didn't even make the damn list)

No need to expand when the list has no credibility.


You needed to watch those games to appreciate how well he played.

In the KC game..Smith had some very important 3rd and 4th down conversions where he was hit in the backfield and carried tacklers for 1st downs.

In the Buffalo game...he had 92 yards at halftime...he carried it 2 times in the second half because we were down by a couple of TD's and it became Marino time.

The guy sucked..he just didn't suck enough to be that high on that list.

 

[jg772006]

No need to expand when the list has no credibility.


You needed to watch those games to appreciate how well he played.

In the KC game..Smith had some very important 3rd and 4th down conversions where he was hit in the backfield and carried tacklers for 1st downs.

In the Buffalo game...he had 92 yards at halftime...he carried it 2 times in the second half because we were down by a couple of TD's and it became Marino time.

The guy sucked..he just didn't suck enough to be that high on that list.

Your insane..Samme Smith was a terrible running back, and turned out to be a real scumbag after football. How in the world can you defend him because of two below average playoff games? Are u high or something?!! THE GUY SUCKED!!!!

 

[Ozzy]

I can tell that you didn't see those games.

He may belong on the list...but nowhere near that high.

What gave you the idea that I did not watch those games?

The part where I knew the scores?

Please don't tell me he was the reason they won, or came close to winning either of those games.

For example: The Bills scored 27 points before halftime, and Marino did throw two picks but he brought them back to tie the game (I'm pretty sure it was at the begining of the fourth quarter) by throwing a bomb (70 yds) to Mark Duper I believe.

 

[unifiedtheory]

What gave you the idea that I did not watch those games?

The part where I knew the scores?

Please don't tell me he was the reason they won, or came close to winning either of those games.

For example: The Bills scored 27 points before halftime, and Marino did throw two picks but he brought them back to tie the game (I'm pretty sure it was at the begining of the fourth quarter) by throwing a bomb (70 yds) to Mark Duper I believe.

Mark Logan fumbled a kickoff in the 2nd half of that game that KILLED us.:boohoo:

 

[Metal Panda]

Worst Dolphins?


1. Jay Fielder

the most ridiculous thing I've ever had the displeasure of reading. Yes, at one point Miami WAY overpaid him, but here's a laundry list of some of the good things Jay did that means he does not belong on a top ten worst list:

1. Come from behind drive against Denver in 2002 WITH A BROKEN THUMB
2. Come from behind victory in 2001 against Buffalo on the road
3. Come from behind victory from off the bench against Washington in 2003
4. Game winning touchdown against Oakland on a keeper up the middle in 2001
5. Phenomenal thanksgiving game on a short week against Dallas, embarassing the Cowboys on national TV

The guy was a scrapper, he didn't have the athletic talent, sometimes he tried to do too much...but he was a decent leader, despite his shortcomings.

Not a great or even 'good' QB by any stretch of the imagination, but for the love of God, you're really saying he's worse than Ray Lucas, Dick Wood, Brian Griese, A.J. Feely, Joey Harrington, and company? what a joke.

 

[Metal Panda]

No need to expand when the list has no credibility.
.

I've seen fundamentalist Christians with logic skills similar to yours--"I don't have to explain myself..it's so because i say so". Congratulations on not knowing the proper tenets of an "argument". Then again, this is a football message board, so I guess I shouldn't have expected such.

 

[Metal Panda]

What gave you the idea that I did not watch those games?

The part where I knew the scores?

Please don't tell me he was the reason they won, or came close to winning either of those games.

For example: The Bills scored 27 points before halftime, and Marino did throw two picks but he brought them back to tie the game (I'm pretty sure it was at the begining of the fourth quarter) by throwing a bomb (70 yds) to Mark Duper I believe.

the Kansas City Chiefs holding penalty was one of the only reasons Miami even won the KC game. It doesn't happen, Lowery boots the game winner.

Oh wait I forgot I obviously didn't see the game either! :)

 

[unifiedtheory]

Worst Dolphins?

H.M. - Nick Saban

H.M. - Kippy Brown

H.M. - Chris Foerster

H.M. - Dave Wannstedt

H.M. - Rick Spielman

H.M. - Tom Olivadatti

10. Eric Green

9. Randall "The Thrill" Hill

8. Sammie Smith

7. Reggie Howard

6. Gene Atkins

5. Michael Stewart

4. Jarvis Williams

3. Vestee Jackson

2. J.B. "Just Burnt" Brown

1. Jay Fielder

Edit: I just realized 6 of my 10 are defensive backs. Jeebus H. Christ, have we had some terrible DBs over the years or what? If it weren't for Madison and Surtain, Jake Scott, and maybe Louis Oliver, I'd be wondering if we'd ever had a decent DB. Oh, and Troy Vincent... too bad we didn't keep him.

J.B. Brown was a 12th round draft pick, the 315th player chosen in the draft. The fact he MADE the NFL, let alone started regularly and played 11 seasons is pretty damn good.

I don't see how you could say Randall Hill was bad for the Dolphins. The guy basically never played for us and we flipped him to Arizona for the draft pick (#7 overall) that turned into Troy Vincent.