Let's be frank.... | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Let's be frank....

datruth55

Hungry for defense
Club Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2004
Messages
21,814
Reaction score
4,246
Location
U.S.A.
I've had time to stew on the game yesterday. I had to stop posting here midway through the 1st quarter because the hate for the Dolphins players, by Dolphins fans, was basically pure stupidity. I haven't seen a fan base hate on it's own players in effort to say "I told you so" more than this one.

Anyway, lets get to it.

1. Ryan Tannehill to Mike Wallace deep is never going to happen with any consistency. Wallace is never going to come back to the ball, never going to high point a ball, never going to make an acrobatic catch over a defender. He's no Calvin Johnson, Jordy Nelson, A.J. Green, Brandon Marshall, DeSean Jackson, Julio Jones or any other elite receiver...he has elite speed but he's no elite receiver. Conversely Tannehill is no Aaron Rodgers. He's never going to have great ball placement down field, he's never going to lead a receiver to the perfect spot down field...just not going to happen.

2. As much as we talked about this receiving corp being the deepest we've had it's still missing that killer element. It's still missing that elite receiver that can take over a game. Wallace is not that guy. There's a reason Mike Wallace was allowed to walk in Pittsburgh and Antonio Brown got the new, big contract.

3. For the last two weeks Lazor has come out and tried to make Wallace the focal point of the passing offense. The results have been extremely poor. Wallace can’t carry the passing offense and you can’t build a passing offense on Wallace. The second half of games we’ve spread it around better and the results have been better but we need to stop trying to get Wallace involved early to the point of ignoring all other receivers. If Wallace can’t remain engaged in the game when he doesn’t get the ball early then that was a complete waste of $60 million dollars. We also didn’t run the ball enough in the first half yesterday. I know Moreno went down on the first run but we abandoned the run in the first half and I think that was a mistake.

4. Lamar Miller is not a 3[SUP]rd[/SUP] down back. Stop throwing him the football. His receiving skills have not improved since college.

5. I mentioned last week that the lack of depth at linebackers was going to hurt us on special teams and that I hoped Sturgis could kick it out of the end zone to prevent any returns. Special teams was a huge bust yesterday…a blocked punt, punt muff and return TD…plus two shanked punts by Fields. Worst special teams performance in one game I’ve ever seen and it wasn’t just on the missing linebackers. Coverage has been an issue since preseason. Special teams needs to get fixed in a hurry.

6. The lack of experienced in our secondary is going to hurt us. Will Davis was no match for Sammy Watkins and the Bills did a great job of matching him up inside on Davis a lot. Davis trailed Watkins over the middle on those shallow crossing routes all day. Made for an easy pitch and catch and Trusnik was nowhere to be found on those shallow crossers. Made the game pretty easy for Manuel…not sure how Watkins seemed wide open on every pass that was thrown to him. I thought this might be an issue with that 5-2 defense they were showing but I don’t think we have much choice right now given our lack of depth at linebacker. Outside of the one run by Spiller the defense did really well against the run but it’s extremely susceptible to the pass. We gambled that Manuel couldn’t beat us but the short passing game with Watkins was effective on their end and the lack of pass rush didn’t help. They gave Seantrel Henderson help against Wake and Vernon couldn’t generate enough pass rush. Interior of the line got almost no penetration.

7. RG remains a big issue on the line. Shelley Smith got abused badly…but we all knew RG was the weakest part of the line anyway. I think I saw Dallas Thomas in there too…got a false start penalty. Until Turner is back I’m going to be uneasy about RG.

8. Through two games Tannehill looks worse in this offense than last year. He doesn’t look comfortable, he’s not attacking the middle of the field (like we all read in the practice tweets), he seems to be pressing and his ball placement has been bad especially in the first half of games. He hasn’t made any big plays but he hasn’t been helped by his receivers either. Last week he threw a perfect deep ball to Sims who dropped it and this week he had a perfect deep ball to Hartline who dropped it. There’s plenty of failure going on through the air but it starts with Tannehill. He’s absolutely got to pick it up.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1) I would settle for decent ball placement down the field. Right now, atrocious is a better description.

2) The WR corps is missing the WR that can make the acrobatic catches out of necessity due to Tannehill's crap ball placement. Landry can make them, but he's not on the field often nor targeted enough yet.

3) Agreed. Tannehill can't take advantage of the one big positive Wallace provides as a deep threat, so he's reduced to being a regular receiver, which he is mediocre (maybe above average) at. Disagree about not running enough though. Miller blows. We were getting nowhere with that. The bigger mistake was trying to force playaction without an effective running game.

4) Agreed. I know what they want him to be, but he'll never be it.

5) Agreed 100%. It was terrible.

6) I was seriously concerned about our secondary over the offseason and when faced by talented WRs, it was shown that that concern was well deserved. On a side note, Watkins is legit. Despite playing through injury, he showed that he is one of those rare receivers who can make any QB look better than they are. As for the DL, Buffalo's line completely shut them down. I'm sure they got pressure at some point, but I honestly can't remember a single instance off the top of my head. Manuel had hours back there. They neutralized our biggest strength.

7) Agreed.

8) Granted, it's only been two games, one of which was against a division rival that completely owns him, but so far he has regressed. Sadly, it's happening in a season before a subpar QB draft in 2015.
 
I didn't get to watch the game and really don't want to at this point. However, I really appreciate the write up. It gives me a good idea of what happened with some good analysis as well.
 
Good write up...

Tannehill has not been good (but he hasn't been as bad as some are making him out to be...), but they are never going to win throwing the ball 50 times and only running it 20....we saw last week what balance can do...also...two weeks and we are seeing a lot of dropped balls....some maybe placement, but some are just bad drops...

Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't see the same offense we saw in the first preseason game (with Wallace and Hartline out). Tannehill seemed more comfortable throwing to Gibby, Matthews and Landry.

The line played pretty poorly as well...

Also, what happen to the passion and excitement we saw in game one...sorely missing...emotions and momentum play a huge role...

I'll try to keep a level head about this game...overreacting to a lost is no different to overreacting to a win...14 more games....
 
I've had time to stew on the game yesterday. I had to stop posting here midway through the 1st quarter because the hate for the Dolphins players, by Dolphins fans, was basically pure stupidity. I haven't seen a fan base hate on it's own players in effort to say "I told you so" more than this one.

Anyway, lets get to it.

1. Ryan Tannehill to Mike Wallace deep is never going to happen with any consistency. Wallace is never going to come back to the ball, never going to high point a ball, never going to make an acrobatic catch over a defender. He's no Calvin Johnson, Jordy Nelson, A.J. Green, Brandon Marshall, DeSean Jackson, Julio Jones or any other elite receiver...he has elite speed but he's no elite receiver. Conversely Tannehill is no Aaron Rodgers. He's never going to have great ball placement down field, he's never going to lead a receiver to the perfect spot down field...just not going to happen.

2. As much as we talked about this receiving corp being the deepest we've had it's still missing that killer element. It's still missing that elite receiver that can take over a game. Wallace is not that guy. There's a reason Mike Wallace was allowed to walk in Pittsburgh and Antonio Brown got the new, big contract.

3. For the last two weeks Lazor has come out and tried to make Wallace the focal point of the passing offense. The results have been extremely poor. Wallace can’t carry the passing offense and you can’t build a passing offense on Wallace. The second half of games we’ve spread it around better and the results have been better but we need to stop trying to get Wallace involved early to the point of ignoring all other receivers. If Wallace can’t remain engaged in the game when he doesn’t get the ball early then that was a complete waste of $60 million dollars. We also didn’t run the ball enough in the first half yesterday. I know Moreno went down on the first run but we abandoned the run in the first half and I think that was a mistake.

4. Lamar Miller is not a 3[SUP]rd[/SUP] down back. Stop throwing him the football. His receiving skills have not improved since college.

5. I mentioned last week that the lack of depth at linebackers was going to hurt us on special teams and that I hoped Sturgis could kick it out of the end zone to prevent any returns. Special teams was a huge bust yesterday…a blocked punt, punt muff and return TD…plus two shanked punts by Fields. Worst special teams performance in one game I’ve ever seen and it wasn’t just on the missing linebackers. Coverage has been an issue since preseason. Special teams needs to get fixed in a hurry.

6. The lack of experienced in our secondary is going to hurt us. Will Davis was no match for Sammy Watkins and the Bills did a great job of matching him up inside on Davis a lot. Davis trailed Watkins over the middle on those shallow crossing routes all day. Made for an easy pitch and catch and Trusnik was nowhere to be found on those shallow crossers. Made the game pretty easy for Manuel…not sure how Watkins seemed wide open on every pass that was thrown to him. I thought this might be an issue with that 5-2 defense they were showing but I don’t think we have much choice right now given our lack of depth at linebacker. Outside of the one run by Spiller the defense did really well against the run but it’s extremely susceptible to the pass. We gambled that Manuel couldn’t beat us but the short passing game with Watkins was effective on their end and the lack of pass rush didn’t help. They gave Seantrel Henderson help against Wake and Vernon couldn’t generate enough pass rush. Interior of the line got almost no penetration.

7. RG remains a big issue on the line. Shelley Smith got abused badly…but we all knew RG was the weakest part of the line anyway. I think I saw Dallas Thomas in there too…got a false start penalty. Until Turner is back I’m going to be uneasy about RG.

8. Through two games Tannehill looks worse in this offense than last year. He doesn’t look comfortable, he’s not attacking the middle of the field (like we all read in the practice tweets), he seems to be pressing and his ball placement has been bad especially in the first half of games. He hasn’t made any big plays but he hasn’t been helped by his receivers either. Last week he threw a perfect deep ball to Sims who dropped it and this week he had a perfect deep ball to Hartline who dropped it. There’s plenty of failure going on through the air but it starts with Tannehill. He’s absolutely got to pick it up.

Thanks for the level headed write up. It was a piss poor day all the way around. As bad as the Offense was I'm way more upset about special team. One mistake leading to points is tough to overcome but when there are multiple it's basically a death nail.
 


Wallace is never going to high point a ball, never going to make an acrobatic catch over a defender.


wallace0-1.gif
 
Getting rid of Carpenter was a big mistake. He makes almost every kick and booms it thru the end zone on kickoffs.
everyone of his kicks from right to left went thru the endzone. Then Sturgis kicks a line drive and it only makes it 2 yards deep giving Spiller the chance.

get a damn kicker that can eliminate the kickoff return for the other team.
 
we've had enough time to fairly form an opinion on Tannehill.

Clear to me that he doesn't have the accuracy needed and is consistently inconsistent like the last half doz QB we've had. And accuracy you cant teach pretty much, and he doesn't show the intensity out there on the field to be this teams leader. We don't have one.....
Fins are again going nowhere this year so playing him and hoping for a miracle is fine with me.

Also knocking a few chips off the old qualification block is Philly and his aimless approach at the 2 min warning going into the half, come on thinking or non thinking like this just tells me he maybe another serious position of need......Hate to say that because personally I think he is a great guy, but "Head coach" I think we may need to do better.....

OH ya Mike Wallace an the acrobatic catch ? That TD catch that he made is one of the nicest acrobatic catches I've seen the Fins make in years...so I don't know what that first poster was seeing...thank you forksphin you put that up while I was writing
 
One of the better posts regarding this game. Dan Marinio probably could not have saved us yesterday with the terrible special teams performance. Dan most probably would have made it closer though. Dan also had some terrible halfs in his career. On a side note look at all of the injuries on the roster. I think it should be noted this may just not be by accident. Moreno who fell down and hurt his own hand has a injury history, Shelly Smith went out also in the 2nd quarter whom also has a history of not staying healthy, Lamar Miller was injured when we drafted him and the list goes on. We have been accumulating a lot of football players in the past couple of years through the draft and free agency that fit that bill and somewhere there is a payback. Just my 2 cents on the subject. Msi going down and Ellerbee going out did not entirly surprise me either, Ellerbee has been known to get hurt when he came over from Baltimore and Msi has been missing games every year since he got here. You need talented players on any team but you also need healthy players perhaps more. Zach Thomas certainly did not miss many games and the good/great ones do not.
 
Back
Top Bottom