maddux or collins

[Link]

Collins. People in Pittsburgh wanted Antwan Randel El to start over Maddox for a reason.

 

[Pepper2Chambers]

Collins. Maddux hasn't been a starter for 2 years. I'm sure that we'll end up with Maddux he's cheaper.

 

[Sirspud]

Maybe its just me but I would have rather re-signed Sage.

 

[In_Flames]

Collins!

 

[dm416]

Collins

 

[POTHEAD]

Very simple
Collins

 

[finsfanrm]

Maddox is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO bad I watched him that one game when Ben was hurt and Batch got hurt. WoW Pitt was holding their breath everytime he dropped back..
I mean think about it he was behind Charlie Batch last year!!
I go Collins, but they both are pretty bad.

 

[GCD960]

when was the last time Collins had a decent O line?

 

[Bellson]

collins without a doubt... but the most probably outcome is gonna be Maddox in a fins jersey next year.

 

[duaneok66]

This thread should have been named " who is going to begin the season as Dolphins starter - Maddox or Collins?"

 

[LarryFinFan]

who would you rather have as a back up

Neither has much left, but both have playing experience...I'd take Collins in case DC can't start at the beginning of the season....but either would work for what we need...

 

[LoHink]

If we get Maddox, and Culp isnt ready to start game one. Be prepared to start the season in the hole.

 

[duaneok66]

If we get Maddox, and Culp isnt ready to start game one. Be prepared to start the season in the hole.

what he said . . .

 

[Hasta]

This should have been a poll...it might have been the most lopsided ever.

Collins

 

[Ohio Fanatic]

collins would be a great backup, just not a great starter.