New details emerge, don't see how Marshall isn't suspended | Page 8 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

New details emerge, don't see how Marshall isn't suspended

Dolphin Dave said:
There is nothing in that artical that would indicate any wrong doing by Marshall. He was stabbed, had defensive wounds and the crazy witch went to jail. What in that would bring any call from the commish other than a simpathy call?
Click to expand...

Well since they dropped charges it seems nothing to show she had any wrong doing. Somebody check Cecil Collins cell see if he is still there
 
dlockz said:
Well since they dropped charges it seems nothing to show she had any wrong doing. Somebody check Cecil Collins cell see if he is still there
Click to expand...

You mean that since he declined to press charges or testify against her that he is now some kind of creepy window climbing freak? That's a pretty big reach.
 
SkapePhin said:
We dont know what goes on in his life other than what gets out to the public... He very well could have been displaying suicidal tendencies in the weeks leading up to the incident... We have no idea.
Click to expand...

True, but he also could not have shown any suicidal tendencies. It is unfair for both you or I to make any sort of judgement on what happened. However, if we are looking strictly at the very limited evidence that has been made public, it points to an attack, not a suicide attempt. Again, this is all conjecture until we are privy to all the evidence, or someone involved actually comes out and says what happened specifically...
 
Buddy said:
You are assuming that during the moment of his potential attempted suicide that he had the mental clarity to think about where his major arteries were and what would be the best place to stab himself for an effective kill. I had a son with BPD who died by a simple drug interaction (accident or suicide, we will never know) and he did some crazy crap that was both brilliant and moronic at the same time in his rages or depressions. I tell you, when someone with BPD falls off the wagon...their brain is somewhere else that most people can't even conceive, much less understand. I truly feel horrible for Brandon and his family as it is a horrific monster of a disease to deal with for everyone involved and almost never ends well. I hope like heck that I am wrong but it would not shock me at all if B-Marsh dies shortly after his football career ends...he needs one hell of a support system and something to ensure that he recognizes his self-worth without football. That is a struggle for all aging athletes but would be armageddon for a superstar with BPD. I pray that he is able to get help and follows through with the treatment.
Click to expand...

I currently work with a very small group of women with Borderline, so unfortunately I have a front row seat to the issues they have. I'm very sorry to hear about the loss of your son. Mental illness is something that no parent should ever have to deal with in their children...
 
Dolphin Dave said:
You mean that since he declined to press charges or testify against her that he is now some kind of creepy window climbing freak? That's a pretty big reach.
Click to expand...

In a domestic violence case esp involving a stabbing the state does not need cooperation to press charges against his wife. In fact in most cases the spouse does not want to press charges. They stated they dropped the charges because of conflicting evidence. Also u totally misunderstood what I meant by Cecil collins. If Brandon did not stab himself and his wife did not stab him who did it was it Cecil Collins lol. Brandon has stated over and over again his wife did not stab him.
never implied that brandon was a guy thats a window freak I will say he is a guy with anger issues and BPD that constantly gets in fights with women that involve the police coming to his house.
 
Topic starter wants miami to sign some more big weapons so he creates this stupid thread, how sad and pathetic ts. Really.
 
MarshallFin1 said:
Topic starter wants miami to sign some more big weapons so he creates this stupid thread, how sad and pathetic ts. Really.
Click to expand...

well I personally thought there was some very good info inarticle that noone had seen on this site as for speculation that marshall will be suspended probably not for this incident we have to wait on the next one.
Like I said Brandon is never boring though
 
Crypt Keeper said:
Proof that Brandon beat his wife. He might not have been arrested, but these disturbing details are not going to sit well with the league offices. Players have been suspended before for not being arrested. Big Ben got 4 games last year, and he never got arrested.

When is Terrell Owens supposed to be ready to take the field? Maybe we can get Randy Moss to come out of retirement.
Click to expand...

Dude, if you read between the lines and listened to his news conference; the dude was trying to hurt himself. His wife probably got hurt while trying to stop him. He basically said I almost killed myself.
 
67Stang said:
Dude, if you read between the lines and listened to his news conference; the dude was trying to hurt himself. His wife probably got hurt while trying to stop him. He basically said I almost killed myself.
Click to expand...

I can buy that but none of us know. he does like to slap around the women lol
 
dlockz said:
Hate to tell u Brandon marshall is not the dolphins. He is a member of the Phins if he does jacked up stuff I agree he should be punished, i dont have double standards for guys that play on my team
Click to expand...

Never said Brandon Marshall was the entire Dolphins, just suggested that his efforts directly influence if we win or lose a football game.

And speaking of double standards, you have been harping, repeatedly, that he should be suspended and that "we just don't know what happened". The police clearly know enough to not arrest him. He didn't do anything worthy of suspension other then be hospitalized. So, he is guilty by association? His name was involved in some way, shape, or form, so he should be suspended? Because he might or might not have done something in the past he is 100% at fault in the future?

Fact: Marshall was never convicted of anything. Fact: While Goodell has previously suspended people on rumors before, he has also reached out a helping hand to players in need and attempted to steer them in the right direction. Fact: Brandon Marshall is attempting to go in the right direction. Fact: Goodell has previously listened to suggestions from outside council concerning individual player cases. Fact: Medical doctors are treating Marshall for a known illness.
Speculation: Goodell will listen and agree with the doctors and will more then likely attempt to help Brandon Marshall if they meet at all, all the while Goodell will be gearing up to go after gun trotting and police fleeing individuals such as Talib and Britt.
 
Spesh said:
Never said Brandon Marshall was the entire Dolphins, just suggested that his efforts directly influence if we win or lose a football game.

And speaking of double standards, you have been harping, repeatedly, that he should be suspended and that "we just don't know what happened". The police clearly know enough to not arrest him. He didn't do anything worthy of suspension other then be hospitalized. So, he is guilty by association? His name was involved in some way, shape, or form, so he should be suspended? Because he might or might not have done something in the past he is 100% at fault in the future?

Fact: Marshall was never convicted of anything. Fact: While Goodell has previously suspended people on rumors before, he has also reached out a helping hand to players in need and attempted to steer them in the right direction. Fact: Brandon Marshall is attempting to go in the right direction. Fact: Goodell has previously listened to suggestions from outside council concerning individual player cases. Fact: Medical doctors are treating Marshall for a known illness.
Speculation: Goodell will listen and agree with the doctors and will more then likely attempt to help Brandon Marshall if they meet at all, all the while Goodell will be gearing up to go after gun trotting and police fleeing individuals such as Talib and Britt.
Click to expand...

I guess u missed something cause i said there was no reason to suspend him at this point.
 
if we're finding out about this now,I can only imagine investigators and league officials might have already kown this....thus far no punishment,and I dont expect some.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom