NFL.Com QB Rankings: Moore, Henne Worst In League | Page 4 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

NFL.Com QB Rankings: Moore, Henne Worst In League

KTOWNFINFAN said:
What an insane comment. Sanchez has never in his career had a QB rating as high as Moore. Sanchez will never be as good as Henne, and Henne isn't even close to Moore. But don't let facts get in the way of a dream.
Click to expand...

I feel bad that you think a higher QB rating means a QB is better.

LikeUntoGod said:
Only a dumb ass trolling Jets fan would think that a 75.3 QB rating for Sanchez in 2010 would make him a top 10 QB. Chad Henne was rated higher, lol.
Click to expand...

I don't evaluate QBs based strictly on rating, those that do that do not understand how to evaluate a QB.

Vaark said:
Moore played with the pressure of rehabilitating his career, for a demoralized winless team with fins fans in the stands actually rooting against him. He rallied the troops, got his offense engaged, didn't sit pouting on the end of the bench when he crapped the bed. Sanchez had no pressure as:
a)he knew from past screw ups that there was a good possibility his team would carry him again
b)he had an AARP backup who would never challenge or replace him
c)he was (my word) "enabled" to continue to reinforce bad habits by mgt. I've said that all along and it was confirmed by at least 2 of his most prominent skill players except they specifically used the word "coddled."

Sanchez played with less pressure than Moore, earned the well-deserved reputation around the league as being unnaturally fragile for someone who's supposed to be a team leader. The litmus test is that I doubt he could unseat the starters including Luck and RG3 on any of the 31 other teams including the Fins, which may in fact be upgrading an already superior QB who isn't fragile.
Click to expand...

So why was he awful the first 4 games when Miami still had somewhat of a chance? I guess it was a coincidence that he started playing well when the team was 0-6/0-7.

finfan54 said:
Matt Moore: Owner of the longest timed drive of all time vs. the Jets and their supposed great D.
Click to expand...

I don't think if it was the longest of all time against the Jets and our D was far from great last year, it actually hasn't been truly great in any of the Rex years.
 
yeah our qb situtation is that dire. look at that list, forget the rankings and i cant find 1 qb in his top 22 that i would rather have moore over. can we debate him against some of the bottom 8, sure.

qb has been bad for so long that people except anything above terrible. i see the homers who want to defend moore, thats great we need to have hope in our guys, but some fail to see the truth.
 
nyjunc said:
I feel bad that you think a higher QB rating means a QB is better.

I feel bad that you think a lower QB rating means a QB is better.



I don't evaluate QBs based strictly on rating, those that do that do not understand how to evaluate a QB.


I don't think if it was the longest of all time against the Jets and our D was far from great last year, it actually hasn't been truly great in any of the Rex years.
Click to expand...

How long was that Matt Moore led drive? After all, Tim Tebow drove the Broncos 95 yards on them for the winning touchdown. But of course Sanchez did help lose the game by throwing a pick 6.
 
Why are Dolphin fans trying to make Matt Moore out to be anything more than he is, great backup and below average starter? Threw or ran for 18 TD and turned it over 15 times (interceptions/fumbles)...18/15 TD/TO ratio is pretty bad by today's standard. Also, played against 9 teams who ranked 19th or below in pass defense for QB rating.
 
Jason Smith is a DIE-HARD Jets fan. Used to do nightly radio shows for years I listened too. HATES Miami with a passion. Take his rankings with a grain of salt
 
Well, that's exactly how most of the fan base feel about our current QB situation, so can't really get mad at them, until we ourselves start supporting the team like we should.
 
moore and henna are both somewhere in the 15-25 range depending on how you feel about either, to have them 31,32 is absurd, they were both top 15 QBR wise when they played but these guys just watch ESPN constantly and make their assessments based on that it seems, I mean Eli is elite but not #1, and Rodgers gets bumped to #5 for one bad game against a tough defense? Cam Newton #7 is silly, sophomore slumps are real and his numbers will drop next year although he could potentially be top 7 eventually, not next year...also The Next Five seem really underrated to me, I'd bump peyton manning (unknown quantity at this point), vick, ryan, and newton to 11-15 with flacco, and have cutler, schaub, stafford and romo top 10 with rivers...after the top 15, the only qb's I'd rather have than moore are Luck, RGIII and Locker all 3 of which are unattainable so let's stick with moore and draft our guy to groom behind him this yr or the next
 
dolfan2909 said:
moore and henna are both somewhere in the 15-25 range depending on how you feel about either, to have them 31,32 is absurd, they were both top 15 QBR wise when they played but these guys just watch ESPN constantly and make their assessments based on that it seems, I mean Eli is elite but not #1, and Rodgers gets bumped to #5 for one bad game against a tough defense? Cam Newton #7 is silly, sophomore slumps are real and his numbers will drop next year although he could potentially be top 7 eventually, not next year...also The Next Five seem really underrated to me, I'd bump peyton manning (unknown quantity at this point), vick, ryan, and newton to 11-15 with flacco, and have cutler, schaub, stafford and romo top 10 with rivers...after the top 15, the only qb's I'd rather have than moore are Luck, RGIII and Locker all 3 of which are unattainable so let's stick with moore and draft our guy to groom behind him this yr or the next
Click to expand...

Dolphins never got the memo that u need a good qb to win anything in the nfl.
 
That article is completely ****. Matt Flynn doesn't get the benefit because he's only played 2 games, yet guys who haven't PLAYED A SNAP are ranked 15 and 22?
 
MarshallFin1 said:
Dolphins never got the memo that u need a good qb to win anything in the nfl.
Click to expand...

They tried with henne, it just didn't work out, but at least we're free to draft someone else now, I'd take that over Matt Ryan perennially leading us to the first rd of the playoffs but never winning the big one
 
the bottom line is matt moore is not good enough...i don't care if you think he's in the tail end of the top 20 which i think is a bit much or if you have him as close to 30 or over the guys not damn good enough to take us anywhere...except the top half of round 1...

and all that bs about moore finishing 12th in qbr or whatever that crap is people bring up here you got to be a fool to think that matt moore sniffs the top 12 of nfl qbs...or you see things through some serious aqua and orange...

oh and slow the roll on that sanchez was close to top 10 stuff a couple years ago....that also reeks of homerism...the one thing that sanchez can hang his hat on is in the postseason the 2 years he's gotten his chance he's not made the mistakes that beat you and made a few plays...so you can't blame him for anything in the postseason...but he's still as inconsistent as ever over a 16 game season...good luck taking that out of him...maybe with sparano there the jets will go back to ground and pound and throw off pa which limits mark sanchez exposure...play it a lot closer to the vest...cause thats what sanchez has shown me needs to happen...he needs to be a part of the equation but not the catalyst...i hope sparano keeps the quick slant in the playbook cause sanchez executes that throw about as well as anyone in the business and santonio holmes runs it to perfection...

and thats it...i'm sick of hearing about mark freakin sanchez and the damn jets in every thread on this board...its like its an obsession with people around here...
 
This journalist is pretty clueless.
I wont try and say Moore should be in the top 15, but, we all know he wasn't THAT bad. For a guy in a Daboll system with Brandon Marshall droppin passes left and right, I'd say he did more than okay.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom