Yeah he gave it his all, and agreed is somewhat underappreciated, but as a qb throwing the ball he was just not very good. Every time he dropped back, the general feeling in my gut was "oh no". The first guy since marino to NOT give me that feeling is Tannehill as far as actually throwing the ball.
I agree he wasn't a good passer but put him on your team the last couple of years and you make the playoffs. Ryan may be a prettier passer but there's more to this position than that. if there wasn't I'd be playing in the NFL.