I'm not calling a fade on 4th down and inches no matter what. I don't care if I have Brandon Marshall, Roberto Wallace, Plaxico Burress, or anybody else. I don't like the playcall.
There's literally an entire page of plays that are higher percentage and make more sense in that situation.
Even still, Henne gave Hartline no chance to make a play on the football with the throw. If you're going to call that low percentage of a play, at least throw it up for grabs where Hartline has a chance to make a play on the football. Henne threw it where it wouldn't get intercepted if Hartline couldn't get it..
That's fine on 1st down... 2nd down... even 3rd down... but not on 4th down.