Plummer | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Plummer

Joey Harrington sucks as a starting QB.
Jake Plummer sucks as a starting QB.

Honestly speaking, what the hell is the difference as backups?
 
Mr772 said:
Maybe a better option would be to pickup David Carr if he is droped for jake. I think pep maybe done but we have to at least give him a little time to see if he can do anything. Lemon is the x factor i don't think we really know if he can be the guy every week. But droping Joey for Carr would be a good move in my opinion.
Click to expand...

that was proposed as well, and i am actually in favor of getting Carr.. however i think he would be in demand and he'd rather go to a team where he'll start.
 
melvindillon said:
Well, I thought we had heard every far-fetched trade/pickup when the Seau thread broke, how about something more realistic?

Getting Jake Plummer. He's a definate upgrade from Harrington / Lemon, and if we do not pick up a QB in the draft, you think the Broncos would go for a Harrington for Plummer trade.

I would actually like it. He's not great. But it's not like we have a "great" QB right now, that is, depending on how Culpepper comes back, and who knows how he will end up.
Click to expand...

Good idea. Trade away Harrington for a pick (someone needs a solid backup), sign Plummer, release CP, and draft a future starter to learn under Plummer. Let Plummer, Lemon, Vick, and the draft pick compete for the starting spot.

GO PHINS~!
 
so-long-Ricky said:
I'm surprised to read all these posts about trading Joey H.

After Joey's performance last year, he has no trade value.
Click to expand...

Pretty much.

What's the point in getting Plummer when Culpepper would just make him the backup anyway. I think Lemon is going to be a fine backup.
 
Dolfan984 said:
Yeah and you're a Joey Harrington fan.
Click to expand...

Really? I didn't know that, thanks for letting me know. I could have sworn I wanted to dump CP, trade JH, get a FA and draft a QB. Wow, thanks for setting me straight.
 
Phanatical said:
Really? I didn't know that, thanks for letting me know. I could have sworn I wanted to dump CP, trade JH, get a FA and draft a QB. Wow, thanks for setting me straight.
Click to expand...

Well you 'were' a Joey Harrington fan. :tongue:

I'm in the dump Joey, get a draft pick QB, and let the 3 guys battle it out for the starting spot bandwagon.

Either way, you slightly insulted me, so I just returned a little.

if you think plummer is better than culpepper....than wow...just wow

edit: okay i looked at your posts and I guess you didn't like Harrington back during the season either. you're 1/2 cool in my book :lol: :)
 
Last edited:
I cant even read through this tread because, it was us who should of gotten Cutler and now here we are at the end of the season talking about picking up the guy he replaced.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom