RUMOR: Brandon Marshall Trade?

[FINS4LIFE16]

Williams
Jennings
Holmes
Welker
Johnson
Fitzgerald
Wallace
Steve Smith
Dwayne Bowe
Jackson

So, who on that list is Marshall better than...tell me please...I'll tell you NONE...

You could even throw more players on the list before him...like Jackson...

You folks who think he is top ten, are the same folks who didn't see 0-4 coming since last year because you can't take the rose-colored glasses off.

that is a terrible list...marshall is better than welker, holmes, (mike?) williams, and bowe...there are a few guys youre missing like another johnson for example

 

[Swantoon]

What has Santonio Holmes done this year to prove he is better than Marshall? And also who is Williams?

 

[dolfaneric12]

With all due respect bro he hasn't lived up to the hype since the trade, and seems to have more conflict, or comments in the media, than catches.

True, but I have a hard time trading a young, top receiver in the NFL when our offense is just bad. I want to keep Marshall and draft Luck (hopefully), because I believe these two would just be awesome together. Plus we trade Marshall, Daniel Thomas is gonna get killed by defenses

 

[Dr. Phin]

It's because he plays for the Dolphins. If he played for any other team he'd be great.

Bull****. Playing for the Dolphins doesn't make him drop balls. Playing for the Dolphins doesn't make him act like a 5 year old. The guy was nothing but a big possession receiver in Denver...and they threw the ball all over the place.

 

[Dolph N.Fan]

Dump Marshall for a 3rd this year and a 3rd next year with conditions that the latter 3rd is upgraded to a 2nd if Marshall gets a certain number of TDs between the trade and the 2013 draft.

 

[PhinsPhan11]

It's because he plays for the Dolphins. If he played for any other team he'd be great.

This.

 

[Fin Fan in Cali]

True, but I have a hard time trading a young, top receiver in the NFL when our offense is just bad. I want to keep Marshall and draft Luck (hopefully), because I believe these two would just be awesome together. Plus we trade Marshall, Daniel Thomas is gonna get killed by defenses

Bro I see you points of view. The thuing you have to ask yourself if you are an owner if we get Luck, is that a match that can work? Is Brandon finally going to pull his head out and be that player? Do you want Marshall's attitude any where near a young player like Luck?

 

[Dr. Phin]

You'd seriously take Welker over Marshall?

Welker would put up Davone Bess numbers in this offense. He did once before, remember? ​He's clearly a product of Tom Brady, a lot like Reggie Wayne is a product of Peyton Manning.

And who is "Williams"? Roy Williams? AHAHA NO

And Santonio Holmes is nowhere near as good as Marshall. Come on.

I'd take Welker over Marshall in a heart beat.

My bad on Williams...I meant Johnson...Calvin....typing fast...

And yes, Holmes makes plays and scores TDs....Marshall doesn't...

 

[Dr. Phin]

that is a terrible list...marshall is better than welker, holmes, (mike?) williams, and bowe...there are a few guys youre missing like another johnson for example

I meant Calvin Johnson...both from Detroit muddled my mind with Williams...

And that was a quick list...you could add Jackson....or even Maclin. (Hell, I would take Decker the way he is progressing this year.)

The point is, I can easily come up with 10 guys I would take over Marshall...you could too!

 

[napsndreds]

marshall is on the do not trade list...im not concerned..these are rumors from people who dont like him as a person. of course people want him. Means even more we should keep em.

 

[Swantoon]

I'd take Welker over Marshall in a heart beat.

My bad on Williams...I meant Johnson...Calvin....typing fast...

And yes, Holmes makes plays and scores TDs....Marshall doesn't...

How many TDs does Holmes have this year? Off the top of my head I think he has about 230 yards and 1 TD. That is your playmaking, TD scoring super stud?

 

[normaldude]

Do it. I've never been a fan of diva receivers anyway.

 

[Lilseb93]

Bull****. Playing for the Dolphins doesn't make him drop balls. Playing for the Dolphins doesn't make him act like a 5 year old. The guy was nothing but a big possession receiver in Denver...and they threw the ball all over the place.

Everyone is mediocre when they come here. I swear this team is cursed. He may have been a baby in Denver but he was still tearing it up.

 

[Mogwai]

Calvin Johnson
Jennings
Holmes
Welker
Andre Johnson
Fitzgerald
Wallace
Steve Smith
Dwayne Bowe
Jackson

Holmes? Psh, nah. There are plenty of others you could debate are ahead of Brandon. Is that Vincent or Desean Jackson? Because they both could be considered better. Nicks, White, Wayne, Stevie, Austin... Bryant, Green, Jones are potentially better.

 

[szes3]

Fans whined for a dominate #1 for years. The Dolphins go out and get one and now you guys just want to dump him? Trading him makes ZERO sense.

^ This

To me sometimes the grass seems greener on the other side of the fence, but so is the water bill.