RUMOR: Brandon Marshall Trade? | Page 8 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

RUMOR: Brandon Marshall Trade?

Swantoon said:
How many TDs does Holmes have this year? Off the top of my head I think he has about 230 yards and 1 TD. That is your playmaking, TD scoring super stud?
Click to expand...

Oh...so you want to go by TD's...well then...

THERE ARE 61 RECEIVERS/TEs WITH MORE TD's THAN THE ALL-MIGHTY BRANDON MARSHALL...
 
Mogwai said:
Holmes? Psh, nah. There are plenty of others you could debate are ahead of Brandon. Is that Vincent or Desean Jackson? Because they both could be considered better. Nicks, White, Wayne, Stevie, Austin... Bryant, Green, Jones are potentially better.
Click to expand...

Yep, you get the idea. The list I put together was quick and debatable, but you could easily put together a list of 10 WR's better than BM...
 
Dr. Phin said:
Oh...so you want to go by TD's...well then...

THERE ARE 61 RECEIVERS/TEs WITH MORE TD's THAN THE ALL-MIGHTY BRANDON MARSHALL...
Click to expand...

No I want to go by who is the better receiver. They have both been proven as great receivers in the past and they are both not playing up to that this season. The only difference is people want to hate on Marshall right now so they want to say guys that may or may not be better are definitely better. I just don't buy it.
 
PhinsPhan11 said:
This.
Click to expand...
Just like Chambers was going to tear it up and Ronnie Brown was going to be a beast when they left. Brandon Marshall was brought here to make this team better and it hasn't worked. The offense is just as bad if not worse. It's one thing to play bad, but add it to his baby act, and is off the field problems, and he is just not worth it. Yes , when the stars are alligned, Brandon Marshall can be a great player, but its not happening here. There is plenty of blame to go around, but Brandon Marshall has his hand in it.
 
no way we trade him we have everything in place for "luck" a #1 wr a probowl lt with j.long and great c in pouncey and a promosing young rb in d.thomas we have alot of good pieces in place for a really good qb to work with next year. b .marshall will benefit from a really good qb throwing him the ball just like in denver when he had j.cutler he even was really good with orton and didnt have to bad season last year considering who was throwing him the ball..
 
houtz said:
If you're going to thrash someone at least give the man credit when hes right. Reading over his profiles he nailed a couple trades, even reported the Kolb contract before anyone else.

The guy hears rumors and reports it as such. Rumors are rumors, for all we know Miami did reach out to the Bengals to get Palmer, and as we all know Miami and Garrard did talk about a contract.
Click to expand...
No, he doesn't. He reports them as "breaking NFL updates" and states there are negotiations in progress when there are not. That's not reporting them as rumors. Of course he gets a couple right, considering he throws out so many. Give a monkey a typewriter and an infinite amount of time and eventually he'll write about an NFL trade that will actually happen.
 
Phantom said:
Just like Chambers was going to tear it up and Ronnie Brown was going to be a beast when they left. Brandon Marshall was brought here to make this team better and it hasn't worked. The offense is just as bad if not worse. It's one thing to play bad, but add it to his baby act, and is off the field problems, and he is just not worth it. Yes , when the stars are alligned, Brandon Marshall can be a great player, but its not happening here. There is plenty of blame to go around, but Brandon Marshall has his hand in it.
Click to expand...

He is still a good player though. He hasn't been awesome but he has played better than a 3rd round pick. Why get rid of him just because he isn't elite.
 
Fin Fan in Cali said:
Bro I see you points of view. The thuing you have to ask yourself if you are an owner if we get Luck, is that a match that can work? Is Brandon finally going to pull his head out and be that player? Do you want Marshall's attitude any where near a young player like Luck?
Click to expand...

I think Marshall could return to form if we got Luck and an offensive coordinator that will give him the ball. It's amazing the difference between what Josh McDaniels did with Marshall compared to Henning and Daboll.

I would definitely take the chance on keeping Marshall with a young player like Luck. Watching the Lions with Stafford and Johnson makes me think we could have the same thing with Luck and Marshall. Really hope that becomes a reality.
 
Nublar7 said:
Fans whined for a dominate #1 for years. The Dolphins go out and get one and now you guys just want to dump him? Trading him makes ZERO sense.
Click to expand...

He isn't a #1 though. That's the point
 
Fin_Frenzy_84 said:
Also there is a lot of rumors that even if we get a new coach we will still keep Ireland. So yes let's trade a top 10 receiver for draft picks and let Ireland strike out with those picks. Some of you fans are just so stupid. You complain about how Ireland can't draft but you still want to trade our best receiver for picks.
Click to expand...

Thank you!

He isn't a #1 though. That's the point
Click to expand...

Lol k. Who are the "#1s" in the league?
 
the only way i would be ok with it is if we get multiple picks or a 1 or 2. if not now is not the time. he could be a piece of a trade if we need to trade up for luck
 
He's mentally fragile and a diva...but the guy can ball...OC'er and QB issues have been the problem.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom