Russsell is better than Quinn

[Captain Lou]

If you watched the 2 qbs matched head to head in their bowl game Brady looked lost out there against LSU's defense. Jamarcus Russell looked much better. I wouldn't waste our first round pick on Brady. He isnt worth it. How many big games did he win at Notre Dame ? Don't even say Michigan State because they aren't good enough to be called even a quality win.

 

[HybridPHIN 23]

it's about how he projects as a pro......... he projects well.

 

[tylerdolphin]

I think this belongs in the draft forum

 

[TotoreMexico]

If you watched the 2 qbs matched head to head in their bowl game Brady looked lost out there against LSU's defense. Jamarcus Russell looked much better. I wouldn't waste our first round pick on Brady. He isnt worth it. How many big games did he win at Notre Dame ? Don't even say Michigan State because they aren't good enough to be called even a quality win.

Draft forum

The same can be said about P. Manning, ohhh wait, he just won the SB

 

[Motion]

If you watched the 2 qbs matched head to head in their bowl game Brady looked lost out there against LSU's defense. Jamarcus Russell looked much better. I wouldn't waste our first round pick on Brady. He isnt worth it. How many big games did he win at Notre Dame ? Don't even say Michigan State because they aren't good enough to be called even a quality win.

What kinda logic is that?

Shall we compare LSU's Defense with ND's?

Supporting cast plays a big factor.

 

[TakeIt2DaHouse]

how many big games did peyton manning win at tennessee??? quinn is the man, great lets draft another daunte culpepper when we already have a one perfect

 

[DonShula84]

If you watched the 2 qbs matched head to head in their bowl game Brady looked lost out there against LSU's defense. Jamarcus Russell looked much better. I wouldn't waste our first round pick on Brady. He isnt worth it. How many big games did he win at Notre Dame ? Don't even say Michigan State because they aren't good enough to be called even a quality win.

Such a stupid stupid reason to think Russell is better. Russell played against NDs defense, Quinn played against LSU's defense. LSU's defense > ND's defense. It's like night and day to compare the two defenses.

Look at Russell's stats in big SEC games, he wasnt exactly lights out against top competition.

 

[montrealfinfan]

If you watched the 2 qbs matched head to head in their bowl game Brady looked lost out there against LSU's defense. Jamarcus Russell looked much better. I wouldn't waste our first round pick on Brady. He isnt worth it. How many big games did he win at Notre Dame ? Don't even say Michigan State because they aren't good enough to be called even a quality win.

It takes a team to win a bowl game, not one player. LSU was a better team end of story in ND had a good defense they wouldn't have put up that many points.

 

[ckparrothead]

If you watched the 2 qbs matched head to head in their bowl game Brady looked lost out there against LSU's defense. Jamarcus Russell looked much better. I wouldn't waste our first round pick on Brady. He isnt worth it. How many big games did he win at Notre Dame ? Don't even say Michigan State because they aren't good enough to be called even a quality win.

And if you watched Joey Harrington face Tom Brady head to head in the second Miami-NE matchup of the season, you would say the same about Harrington over Brady.

But that is why it is, quite frankly, stupid to trust in QB-vs-QB individual game matchups, and even more stupid to judge a quarterback based on one game.

 

[NJFINSFAN1]

AJ Feeley beat Brady, lets get him back!:shakeno:

 

[badfoot]

I suppose leaf was better than manning too?..lol

 

[Captain Lou]

Draft forum

The same can be said about P. Manning, ohhh wait, he just won the SB

Brady Quinn isn't even in the same catagory as Peyton. Quinn plays a weak as schedule, and didn't beat any of the good team they did manage to play. Peyton placed in the SEC. He won big games, he just didn't beat FLORIDA. I think you may be mentally ill you think Quinn will amount to half as much as Peyton at the NFL level. It's really a moot point anyways because we won't be drafting him.

 

[DonShula84]

Brady Quinn isn't even in the same catagory as Peyton. Quinn plays a weak as schedule, and didn't beat any of the good team they did manage to play. Peyton placed in the SEC. He won big games, he just didn't beat FLORIDA. I think you may be mentally ill you think Quinn will amount to half as much as Peyton at the NFL level. It's really a moot point anyways because we won't be drafting him.

Where did he even imply that he felt that?

 

[jlfin]

What kinda logic is that?

Shall we compare LSU's Defense with ND's?

Supporting cast plays a big factor.

Logic is irrelevant with some of the posters on this forum

 

[Irish Phin Fan]

Brady Quinn isn't even in the same catagory as Peyton. Quinn plays a weak as schedule, and didn't beat any of the good team they did manage to play. Peyton placed in the SEC. He won big games, he just didn't beat FLORIDA. I think you may be mentally ill you think Quinn will amount to half as much as Peyton at the NFL level. It's really a moot point anyways because we won't be drafting him.

I don't recall him saying anything comparing Manning to Quinn. Think before you type.