Saban's Rating Through Day 1
- Thread starter Phin_Phan
- Start date
dolphindan1970
Seasoned Veteran
B plus on day 1...addressed need at RB, got help for the future and even back-ups for next year on defense.Crowder's injuries do worry me, but a good chance pick in the 3rd for someone who is an awesome player, IF he can stayt away from the injuries.
I think Day 2 needs to take some shots at some more O-line help and maybe some secondary help for down the road, if anyone is there.
I think Day 2 needs to take some shots at some more O-line help and maybe some secondary help for down the road, if anyone is there.
- Joined
- May 25, 2003
- Messages
- 3,306
- Reaction score
- 3,197
For First day picks I'd give Saban an A. I mentioned in an earlier thread that we will see this word applied to each of Saban's picks, Versatility. All of the day 1 picks are players that give off a contagious aura of competitiveness and desire on every play. They are explosive players at whatever job their coach gives them. They are consistent and must be accounted for by the opposition.
Phin_Phan
Practice Squad
byroan said:
HAHA! I dont think anyone is truly right our wrong on this website.....are you saying what I personally believe is wrong?? How can your own opinion be wrong?? haha it doesnt make sense.
haha "YOUR WRONG AND IM RIGHT!!!" :cry:
Fritz27
Seasoned Veteran
A
We have guys that will have an impact now and an impact in the future.
We have guys that will have an impact now and an impact in the future.
Dol-Fan Dupree
Manning to Tyree = Best SB Play EVER!!!!
Phin_Phan said:
someone elses opinion could be that your opinion is wrong.
Regan21286
Wa Wa Wee Wa
A-. Brown and maybe Roth were good picks though it would've been nice to see if they could trade down or get Rodgers. Crowder's too much of a gamble IMO. Still needs to draft a QB, OL, DT, S, and WR. If he fills the QB spot with McPherson and WR with Craig Bragg, I'll give em an A. If he gets Ben Emanuel as an undrafted FA S, I'll give him an A+ (sorry for being a UCLA homer).
fishypete
FinHeaven Elite
TeeMoney said:
And Roth and Crowder are great if you ever play in a bar....or outside one. LOL.
FinFanInMD
Practice Squad
B+
Phin_Phan
Practice Squad
Dol-Fan Dupree said:
There's a difference of being "wrong" or "disagreeing" we obviously disagree on the subject, but you cant say IM WRONG for what I believe, u just disagree.
LOL but who cares! the thread is about Saban and the picks, not who's right or wrong, if everyone said that about everyone's opinion we wouldnt get anywhere, so lets leave it at that.
hopefully......
I'd say a B+ is fair. "A" range would have been trading down....even if to take whatever deal Cleaveand was offering to get an extra 3rd rounder or so (i'm assuming Saban wanted a 2nd) as they wanted Edwards and we took Brown anyways.
I'd say a B+ is fair. "A" range would have been trading down....even if to take whatever deal Cleaveand was offering to get an extra 3rd rounder or so (i'm assuming Saban wanted a 2nd) as they wanted Edwards and we took Brown anyways.
Chubby
SUPERFAN
B-I still think he should have picked Barnes in the 2nd Round, Hes a mean tough LEft Tackle and we need an upgrade in that postition on our team.
CHubbs
CHubbs
The Confessor
Doesnt play well with others
Losman7 said:
Hey Loserman, explain two (2) things.
1. Who exactly did you pick up again?
2. Is you're team so pitiful that you have to come hang out with the good team to get a point across?
I give Saban a low A. We still need to address the o-line. Plenty of QB still available, but not O-liners
Last edited by a moderator: