I am having the same problems as you Awsi. Otherwise I would quote your post. A friend gave me that list but you're right, not quite complete. In fact, he intended it only to reflect the 2014 class. I compiled the rest earlier today. These are all players that appeared either on ESPN's Top 50 or 247's Top 50, with an asterisk awarded if one of the services gave the player a 5-Star rating (hence two asterisks means both services did it):
2015 Class
DT Trenton Thompson, Georgia**
S Derwin James, Florida State**
DE Josh Sweat, Florida State**
CB Kevin Tolliver, LSU**
CB Iman Marshall, USC*
DT Tim Settle, Virginia Tech*
RB Kerryon Johnson, Auburn*
CB Donte Jackson, LSU*
LB Malik Jefferson, Texas A&M*
WR Deon Cain, Clemson*
QB Josh Rosen, UCLA*
WR Calvin Ridley, Alabama*
CB Tarvarus McFadden, Florida State*
OG Maea Teuhema, SE Missouri State
DE Arden Key, LSU
WR Christian Kirk, Texas A&M
RB Ronald Jones, USC
RB Damien Harris, Alabama
DB Minkah Fitzpatrick, Alabama
LB Roquan Smith, Georgia
DT Da'Ron Payne, Alabama
2014 Class
DE Da'Shawn Hand, Alabama**
S Quin Blanding, Virginia**
DL Andrew Brown, Virginia**
CB Tony Brown, Alabama**
DE Lorenzo Carter, Georgia**
RB Bo Scarborough, Alabama*
QB Kyle Allen, Houston*
LB Rashaan Evans, Alabama*
RB Royce Freeman, Oregon*
RB Nick Chubb, Georgia*
LB Tre' Williams, Auburn*
DE Chad Thomas, Miami*
LB Clifton Garrett, LSU*
DB Ermon Lane, Florida State
LB Jacob Pugh, Florida State
S Damon Webb, Ohio State
CB Arrion Springs, Oregon
RB Sony Michel, Georgia
OL K.C. McDermott, Miami
2013 Class
LB Matthew Thomas, Florida State**
RB Keith Ford, Texas A&M
TE Adam Breneman, UMass
I'd have done the Rivals 5-Star players but they seem to give something like 35 players a 5-Star rating every year. Too many.