The Debate is FINALLY settled...The Fiedler haters.....WIN!!!

[twohype]

Is there any doubt? Any? Any? I dare a Fiedler hugger to come in here and defend this piece of crap.

Well said:cooldude: Jay 'I can't throw deep' Fiedler needs to kiss da bench quick:eek: . What on earth is Wanny thinking Jay simply has no upside potential:shakeno: bench him:yell:

 

[davster82]

What a worthless post.

My sentiments exactly.

 

[Meatwad]

Heh, I think someone is having Brian Griese flashbacks. You might want to see a few more games before making that claim, don't you think?

I haven't missed a single dolphins game for 5 years until today. I've always hated Fiedler, even when he had a couple good games because I know the next week he would suck it up again.

 

[finataxia24]

bench jay

 

[Section126]

It is time....that we have the decency to put an end to the Fiedler Era....

The Fiedler "thing" is like an old sick dying Dog....you just have to put it to sleep.

I see no more need to even respond to any debate on the merits of Jay Fiedler....they can cut him tomorrow for all I care.

 

[minus]

It is time for Fiedler to hold clip board but I'm not sure A.J can be QB of the future.

DW better start A.J and stick with him even if he sucks because at least we will get high draft pick.

 

[Lungoystr]

I haven't missed a single dolphins game for 5 years until today. I've always hated Fiedler, even when he had a couple good games because I know the next week he would suck it up again.

And I will say it again since I didn't make it clear the first time.....don't you think that you should watch A.J. in a few more games before proclaiming us a better team? Seems to me that quite a few people were cheering the same thing after Griese shredded San Diego. Well, we all know how the Brian Griese experiment worked out, don't we?

 

[Section126]

I gave up on him after the 2nd NE game last year....some of you gave up on him earlier....

That piece of fecal matter cost us this game.....He is a back up and nothing else.

These are the plays that piece of crap missed:

First quarter:

Missed a wide open Booker on a 20 yard in cut...RESULT: incomplete pass to Thompson.

Chambers beat Rolle badly at the end of the first quarter on a stutter stop and go and Fiedler threw underneath to Gordon........He had all day....Good protection.

McMike was wide open on a seam route when The Titans had a busted coverage on their 3 deep when Tank Williams jumped a Chambers skiny post of which Fiedler threw it and almost got it intercepted.

2nd Quarter:

Combination route with Thompson and Booker designed to identify Man coverage.......Booker breaks out of the combo route to be wide open for at least a 15 yard gain.Fiedler never looked his way...It was a combo route which means that they are the primary recievers and this moron doesn't even look that way?

Play action pass actually brings in Tank Williams (he was a disaster...he was out of position all day), Chambers smokes Dyson (one of a few times that Chambers was one on one with Dyson)....Fiedler throws it away....good protection.

This pile of crap that is Fiedler left a massive amount of plays on the field in the first half.....

The Titans were primed to be BLOWN OUT today...But that A-hole Fiedler did not cash in at all.

THANK GOD...that the final nail in the coffin of Jay Fiedler's dolphin career has been driven in......I HOPE!!!!

Here was my post from another thread...how anybody can defend this POS is beyond me......

 

[Phishstix]

they both were sorry today from most accounts. imo i know jay ain't the answer, and i'm definately not sold on aj yet. this really sucks, as our next regular qb may be in college right now

 

[twohype]

First, I would appreciate it if you grew up instead of calling names.

Second, why didn't we make the playoffs the past two years, maybe because we didn't utilize the tools we had. Running the ball 40 times does not constitute us using our tools.

I won't hide hero, I am here, just don't run away like you did with Griese.

In general, when teams put 7 or 8 in the box to stop the run your QB should smile since now the QB can go down field. Bottomline Jay SIMPLY NOT MAKE PLAYS DOWNFIELD. No NFL D fears Jay. It's been 4 years, Jay has NO MORE UPSIDE POTENTIAL:eek: . Jay's arm is still weak, he still can't throw deep and forget about the deep out. Jay's a dump off passer pure and simple. If that fits a team then that's OK, however the Phins need a QB that has the potential to make plays downfield (if the OL plays decent) and AJ is currently our ONLY option so Jay needs to kiss da bench - now:eek:

 

[Meatwad]

And I will say it again since I didn't make it clear the first time.....don't you think that you should watch A.J. in a few more games before proclaiming us a better team? Seems to me that quite a few people were cheering the same thing after Griese shredded San Diego. Well, we all know how the Brian Griese experiment worked out, don't we?

If Feeley throws 2 INT's a game and can't drive this team down the field, than I will concede that Feeley sucks as bad as Fiedler.

 

[davster82]

I'll defend Jay against the name calling and personal insults that are extremely prevalent on this board and childish. Anyone who hates Jay just doesn't deserve a response because you would disregard it anyway. If you want to hate the fact that Jay has started for us, go ahead. But if you can't admit that this guy has given his all for this team and has showed extreme heart and courage, most of your posts are probably garbage anyway.

 

[Section126]

I'll defend Jay against the name calling and personal insults that are extremely prevalent on this board and childish. Anyone who hates Jay just doesn't deserve a response because you would disregard it anyway. If you want to hate the fact that Jay has started for us, go ahead. But if you can't admit that this guy has given his all for this team and has showed extreme heart and courage, most of your posts are probably garbage anyway.

Heart and courage and 85 cents will get you a cup of coffee.....ever heard of Talent? Jay has NONE....

BTW...he knew that his job was on the line and he decided to have the worst game of his career.....He is a bum.

 

[KB21]

Sam Simmons has a lot of heart and courage. Where did it get him?

 

[Lungoystr]

If Feeley throws 2 INT's a game and can't drive this team down the field, than I will concede that Feeley sucks as bad as Fiedler.

Then I assure you sir that you will be more fair in your assessment than many on this board. The "anyone but Fiedler" crowd is just rediculous. We should all be careful what we ask for, we just might get it (see Griese and Lucas). I hope that Feeley (or Fiedler if he is given the start) has success the rest of this season as I am a Dolphin fan and not a fan of any one player on this team. I'm sure that you feel the same.