The Key to Signing Free Agents. | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

The Key to Signing Free Agents.

KB21

Club Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2001
Messages
10,065
Reaction score
68
Many of you seem upset that Miami hasn't jumped into the bidding wars for some of the top free agents on the market. The reason they haven't is that Nick Saban knows that free agency isn't the way to build a team.

The key to finding free agent talent is getting guys who aren't the big name guys. Guys who may be on the verge of breaking out. Typically, the unknown players that sign free agent contracts tend to be the best free agent signings. These are guys who are signed cheap and break out to become above average players.

From 1995 till this point, the best free agent signing the Miami Dolphins had isn't a big name player. It isn't Brock Marion. It isn't Kevin Donnalley. They were good free agent signings, but the best, IMO, was Brian Walker. Brian was a street free agent when Miami first got him in 1998. He became a ballhawking safety in the Dolphins system. He went on to sign a big contract with the Seahawks, got cut, came back to Miami, and lead the Dolphins in interceptions. Plus, he was a force in the run. He fit the Dolphins scheme very well, and he has been a non-descript player for other teams. Amazing how that happens, but it does.

Some of you may snub your nose at the Travares Tillman type of signings, but you just never know. Jamie Nails was a street free agent that played at a near pro bowl level until he injured his knee.

You can't go on big spending sprees in free agency. Miami tried that in 1995, and it didn't work. Washington has done that religously over the past few years, and it hasn't worked.

Teams are built through the draft, and they are augmented through free agency. New England won their first Superbowl by being frugal in free agency with the signings of unknown players like David Patten, Mike Compton, Joe Andruzzi, and Larry Izzo and veteran players like Roman Phifer and Ted Washington.
 
KB21 said:
Many of you seem upset that Miami hasn't jumped into the bidding wars for some of the top free agents on the market. The reason they haven't is that Nick Saban knows that free agency isn't the way to build a team.

The key to finding free agent talent is getting guys who aren't the big name guys. Guys who may be on the verge of breaking out. Typically, the unknown players that sign free agent contracts tend to be the best free agent signings. These are guys who are signed cheap and break out to become above average players.

From 1995 till this point, the best free agent signing the Miami Dolphins had isn't a big name player. It isn't Brock Marion. It isn't Kevin Donnalley. They were good free agent signings, but the best, IMO, was Brian Walker. Brian was a street free agent when Miami first got him in 1998. He became a ballhawking safety in the Dolphins system. He went on to sign a big contract with the Seahawks, got cut, came back to Miami, and lead the Dolphins in interceptions. Plus, he was a force in the run. He fit the Dolphins scheme very well, and he has been a non-descript player for other teams. Amazing how that happens, but it does.

Some of you may snub your nose at the Travares Tillman type of signings, but you just never know. Jamie Nails was a street free agent that played at a near pro bowl level until he injured his knee.

You can't go on big spending sprees in free agency. Miami tried that in 1995, and it didn't work. Washington has done that religously over the past few years, and it hasn't worked.

Teams are built through the draft, and they are augmented through free agency. New England won their first Superbowl by being frugal in free agency with the signings of unknown players like David Patten, Mike Compton, Joe Andruzzi, and Larry Izzo and veteran players like Roman Phifer and Ted Washington.


:clap: Excellent post KB
 
Frankly I don't consider Kevin Carter to be a small signing either. If the guy were three years younger, IMO he'd be the #1 signing in FA.
 
I agree with you in spirit. Terrell Owens and Javon Kearse sure helped Philly, though.
 
I think this is all fine and good, but we also have to be realists here. Tillman and those of his ilk are often going to be camp fodder or special teamers. You dig out several rocks when you're finding diamonds in the rough.
 
Terrell Owens was a trade acquisition. Jevon Kearse was overpaid, and I don't think he made that much of a difference. The Eagles got considerably worse as a run defense.
 
Tillman will probably play safety. He needs to stay healthy.
 
TO and Kearse are exceptions, though. if you think about it, there have only been a handful of difference makers in FA. it just makes more sense to build thru the draft.
 
Jimmy James said:
I think this is all fine and good, but we also have to be realists here. Tillman and those of his ilk are often going to be camp fodder or special teamers. You dig out several rocks when you're finding diamonds in the rough.

This is realism.

Look at the laundry list of big name free agents who have signed big contracts only to totally flop in the process:

Sean Gilbert
Eric Swann
Dana Stubblefield
Derek Alexander
Eric Green
Chester McFatass, I mean McGlockton
Daryl Williams

Just to name a few.
 
The Dolphins will be a team full of waiver-wire players, draft picks and a sprinkle of big FA acquistions.

The anti-raiders/redskins AKA the way to run a NFL Franchise.
 
KB21 said:
This is realism.

Look at the laundry list of big name free agents who have signed big contracts only to totally flop in the process:

Sean Gilbert
Eric Swann
Dana Stubblefield
Derek Alexander
Eric Green
Chester McFatass, I mean McGlockton
Daryl Williams

Just to name a few.

Yeah -- I agree with what you're saying. I don't think there is anything wrong with the big FA signing when there is a need, cap space, and everything else works out. It shouldn't be an every year thing, though.

At the same time, this will be a worse place if we get excited every time we sign a Tillman, expect him to be the guy, and then get bitter about it when he ends up being a reserve, a special teams guy, or camp fodder.
 
KB21 said:
Many of you seem upset that Miami hasn't jumped into the bidding wars for some of the top free agents on the market. The reason they haven't is that Nick Saban knows that free agency isn't the way to build a team.

The key to finding free agent talent is getting guys who aren't the big name guys. Guys who may be on the verge of breaking out. Typically, the unknown players that sign free agent contracts tend to be the best free agent signings. These are guys who are signed cheap and break out to become above average players.

From 1995 till this point, the best free agent signing the Miami Dolphins had isn't a big name player. It isn't Brock Marion. It isn't Kevin Donnalley. They were good free agent signings, but the best, IMO, was Brian Walker. Brian was a street free agent when Miami first got him in 1998. He became a ballhawking safety in the Dolphins system. He went on to sign a big contract with the Seahawks, got cut, came back to Miami, and lead the Dolphins in interceptions. Plus, he was a force in the run. He fit the Dolphins scheme very well, and he has been a non-descript player for other teams. Amazing how that happens, but it does.

Some of you may snub your nose at the Travares Tillman type of signings, but you just never know. Jamie Nails was a street free agent that played at a near pro bowl level until he injured his knee.

You can't go on big spending sprees in free agency. Miami tried that in 1995, and it didn't work. Washington has done that religously over the past few years, and it hasn't worked.

Teams are built through the draft, and they are augmented through free agency. New England won their first Superbowl by being frugal in free agency with the signings of unknown players like David Patten, Mike Compton, Joe Andruzzi, and Larry Izzo and veteran players like Roman Phifer and Ted Washington.

You should also mention nice trades. NE got Dillon for chump change. We blew the RW trade. But there is a risk, you sign an unknown and he stays unknown. Also, Nails didn't really last otherwise we wouldn't have paid James big bucks.
 
Back
Top Bottom