That's absolutely classic. The happy adjusters know no limit of absurdity. Peyton Manning in 1999 did exactly what a premier prospect is supposed to do. He completely turned around the fortunes of both his team and his own play. The Colts went from 3-13 in Manning's rookie season of 1998 to to 13-3 in 1999. I love how you tried to let that little tidbit slide, hoping no one would notice. Again, that's the mode of a pathetic happy adjuster. Manning may have had a poor game at Buffalo in the finale but the only thing at stake was possible top seed above Jacksonville. The playoff berth was long established thanks to Manning's superb play all season. He vaulted from 6.5 YPA and 5.2 adjusted yards per attempt in 1998 to 7.8 YPA and 7.5 AYA in 1999.
Southbeach's point is valid. Tannehill had no excuse in the final two games. Miami was bet up to a 7.5 point home favorite in the finale hosting the Jets. Tannehill didn't even score the spread. It's laughable to compare that situation to Marino's 1999 playoff loss to Jacksonville, a road game against a 14-2 team that was an 8 point favorite. We were home to a 7-8 Jets team with Geno Smith at quarterback.
Tannehill's numbers stayed the same from rookie to second year, unlike Manning, because he's never been elite. He was forced into the top tier of the first round and now we hope for a modest payoff.
The scary aspect is that the happy adjuster mind attempts these type of desperate comparisons all the time. If there is nobody to call them out on it they actually stand unchallenged. But I have to credit this one for particular value. I needed a whopper of a laugh.