How does that make you all feel?
Thoughts On This Play By Tua - Is The Commentator Right?
- Thread starter phinsforlife
- Start date
He posts nonsense and we all follow.
I don't post much but long time member. Don't feed into it.
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2006
- Messages
- 2,261
- Reaction score
- 3,798
I have no doubt that from that point on the field Tua could throw it out of the end zone if he wanted. That wasn’t the discussion, it was about could he have placed it better? The all-22 on that play shows the safety that comes on at the end taking a hard angle so I don’t think Reek would’ve scored.
This forum used to be banter back forth about different point view. Now its 5th grade school bickering
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2006
- Messages
- 2,261
- Reaction score
- 3,798
I’m literally trying to have a back and forth discussion and you are the one who’s not staying on topic…this could be a legitimate debate
If you can't see through the sheer curtain of original post and why it was started i can't help you
Gsmack_42
Club Member
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2009
- Messages
- 6,021
- Reaction score
- 12,415
Go back and look at every thread he’s made and you would know why.
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2006
- Messages
- 2,261
- Reaction score
- 3,798
Article - Top 5 Miami Dolphins OTA Storylines
Seems like a good list, but one big thing is absent from my perspective. Does McDaniel run things any differently? Work the guys harder, more screaming and yelling, anything different, or still a somewhat laid back approach? I think he missed his first chance to do something differently, by...
finheaven.com
Hal Habib On What The Dolphins Can Learn From The Panthers
I would go one step further, and say the Panthers and Heat. Both tough and gritty organizations. Because their respective owners made a decision to hire capable GMs, who are given full command of the organization, and who are good at talent evaluation at the individual level, understand the...
finheaven.com
Chop, Chubb, Phillips
Article below on Chop. It will be interesting how the trio is used. Questions are: -How will Phillips and Chubb look coming back off injury -How is Chop used in combination with those two? Chop needs to be a 3 down player as opposed to just a situational pass rusher. Need to see if he can...
finheaven.com
Holy Purdy - I Didn't Think The 49ers Would Do It
Purdy's deal might not be the top of today's market, but it is close, and still a ton of money. If this story is right (link below), 5 and $265mm ($53mm AAV) with $181mm guaranteed. You don't know for sure until the small print is out, but wow. In compare, Tua got $167mm guaranteed, and an...
finheaven.com
Achane Wants 1,000 Yards On The Ground
-Will the OL be good enough? -Will McDaniel commit to the run enough? -Can Achane take the pounding with this many carries? And if Achane gets this many carries, is this the best way to use him or will it really shorten his career (and put him at too much risk this season) or will the load be...
finheaven.com
Tyreek Reeking Again
Even though this is the truth (give or take), you don't publicly not support your own QB this way either. The correct answer is publicly, you include Tua in the list, even if you don't believe it. He is still somehow technically a team captain too. Will be interesting if he is on the team...
finheaven.com
I Am Thinking Shula's Record Is Now 100% Safe From Bellicheat
This whole situation in North Carolina with his 24 year old "girlfriend" is quite messy. I suspect everyone has heard about their behavior during a recent interview with CBS -...
finheaven.com
Literally in his last 10 threads created
Thats why @phinsforlife disengages in posts that he starts .
Gsmack_42
Club Member
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2009
- Messages
- 6,021
- Reaction score
- 12,415
Go back and see his month long Tua thread fest and get back to me.Article - Top 5 Miami Dolphins OTA Storylines
Seems like a good list, but one big thing is absent from my perspective. Does McDaniel run things any differently? Work the guys harder, more screaming and yelling, anything different, or still a somewhat laid back approach? I think he missed his first chance to do something differently, by...
Hal Habib On What The Dolphins Can Learn From The Panthers
I would go one step further, and say the Panthers and Heat. Both tough and gritty organizations. Because their respective owners made a decision to hire capable GMs, who are given full command of the organization, and who are good at talent evaluation at the individual level, understand the...
Chop, Chubb, Phillips
Article below on Chop. It will be interesting how the trio is used. Questions are: -How will Phillips and Chubb look coming back off injury -How is Chop used in combination with those two? Chop needs to be a 3 down player as opposed to just a situational pass rusher. Need to see if he can...
Holy Purdy - I Didn't Think The 49ers Would Do It
Purdy's deal might not be the top of today's market, but it is close, and still a ton of money. If this story is right (link below), 5 and $265mm ($53mm AAV) with $181mm guaranteed. You don't know for sure until the small print is out, but wow. In compare, Tua got $167mm guaranteed, and an...
Achane Wants 1,000 Yards On The Ground
-Will the OL be good enough? -Will McDaniel commit to the run enough? -Can Achane take the pounding with this many carries? And if Achane gets this many carries, is this the best way to use him or will it really shorten his career (and put him at too much risk this season) or will the load be...
Tyreek Reeking Again
Even though this is the truth (give or take), you don't publicly not support your own QB this way either. The correct answer is publicly, you include Tua in the list, even if you don't believe it. He is still somehow technically a team captain too. Will be interesting if he is on the team...
I Am Thinking Shula's Record Is Now 100% Safe From Bellicheat
This whole situation in North Carolina with his 24 year old "girlfriend" is quite messy. I suspect everyone has heard about their behavior during a recent interview with CBS -...
Literally in his last 10 threads created
@Finsup1981 enjoy!
BrowardDolfan
Active Roster
Safety right there over the top. Could the ball have been place a little better? Sure, but it's not an example of a pass that makes Tua "good", but not "great". If anything, it is a positive example of a pass from Tua. If he doesn't place the ball between the CB and S, the ball is intercepted.
zechs
Active Roster
so theres a good yt channel called qbschoool.. now this guy knows his stuff.
he himself goes over games and has several Tua videos, in this he points to throws that Tua over throws tyreek and waddle, hell big ones i can remember is in jags startin game last year.
now what he says, and tbh i believe it, alot of the time from way Tua throws it.. he dilberatly tends to under throw rather then over throw and he breaks down the logic, and it makes sense.
and the easiest logic is an over thrown pass is uncatchable, a wr cannot suddenly gain more speed when he is already running flat out.. so its an uncatchable ball, or also leads to ints from saftys(ala josh allen til this year when he was clearly neutered by coaching staff in his long ball plays(you can check the stats and see this btw). HOWEVER an underthrown ball a wr can do what you see tyreek do here and in the mahomes one also linked, he has a chance to come back and make a play.. this weak arm narrative is over done.. as said theres literal footage of him over throwing hill and waddle.
as for the guys analysis , he is clueless one as stated you CLEARLY see the safty over the top.. so if he over throws its a turn over if he lands it on the money he is instantly hit by said safty and gains 2-3 yards more. in the end this entire analysis is based on a what if, here I feel the throw made was the safe choice to stop the turn over in hope to get another crack at it on the next down. but to state the weak arm narrative is boring, sure he cannot cannon it like allen or herbert, but then tbh they throw like a man playin fetch with a dog, they don't aim they just launch it which is why they both produce massive amounts of ints, orrrr contiuniously over throw wide open recievers.
I am all for callin Tua out on things he doesnt do well, like being smart with sliding, or fact he is an injury liablity BUT calling him out on his ability to throw the rock ain't it
he himself goes over games and has several Tua videos, in this he points to throws that Tua over throws tyreek and waddle, hell big ones i can remember is in jags startin game last year.
now what he says, and tbh i believe it, alot of the time from way Tua throws it.. he dilberatly tends to under throw rather then over throw and he breaks down the logic, and it makes sense.
and the easiest logic is an over thrown pass is uncatchable, a wr cannot suddenly gain more speed when he is already running flat out.. so its an uncatchable ball, or also leads to ints from saftys(ala josh allen til this year when he was clearly neutered by coaching staff in his long ball plays(you can check the stats and see this btw). HOWEVER an underthrown ball a wr can do what you see tyreek do here and in the mahomes one also linked, he has a chance to come back and make a play.. this weak arm narrative is over done.. as said theres literal footage of him over throwing hill and waddle.
as for the guys analysis , he is clueless one as stated you CLEARLY see the safty over the top.. so if he over throws its a turn over if he lands it on the money he is instantly hit by said safty and gains 2-3 yards more. in the end this entire analysis is based on a what if, here I feel the throw made was the safe choice to stop the turn over in hope to get another crack at it on the next down. but to state the weak arm narrative is boring, sure he cannot cannon it like allen or herbert, but then tbh they throw like a man playin fetch with a dog, they don't aim they just launch it which is why they both produce massive amounts of ints, orrrr contiuniously over throw wide open recievers.
I am all for callin Tua out on things he doesnt do well, like being smart with sliding, or fact he is an injury liablity BUT calling him out on his ability to throw the rock ain't it