We need to deal Marshall for draft picks | Page 9 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

We need to deal Marshall for draft picks

Uh no, we should keep Marshall to be Luck's #1. You don't trade away good players to MAYBE get equal value in the draft, unless they are old.
 
dolpns13 said:
you have pipe dreams if you think were getting back what we invested in marshall. also i have a theory in that marshall is purposefully dropping passes as to also set us up. he wants a realy qb just as much as we do.
Click to expand...

I said this earlier and I agree. Marsh wants a real QB here, he's not trying to hard out there.
 
Brandon Marshall has dropped as many td's this year, as he has scored since he got here. He's our #1 reciever, and is just as much as a problem with this offense scoring as anyone else.
 
Josh McDaniel made 2 good decisions in Denver.

1. Trading Brandon Marshall to Miami for 2 2nd round picks.
2. Letting Mike Nolan walk.
 
So we finally get a real #1 WR and you want to trade him away? That makes total sense. So he has had a few drops. While we are at it, should we trade away Wake too?
 
Unbelievable that some of u are still calling Marshall an elite WR. Yeah, he's a leading WR alright - leads the NFL in drops and wife slapping.

And u definitely trade him. Plenty of good reasons:

-Use his money for TE, safety and OL upgrades.
-Can probably get a 2nd rounder back.
-he's a huge suspension risk.
-don't want him anywhere near Luck.
 
petefins said:
This thread is ridiculous. Marshall is a top 10 receiver. You keep those kind of players. Not trade them.
Click to expand...

I doubt he is considered a top 10 WR by anyone other than some Miami fans. A top 10 WR doesn't drop the kind of ball he does. At this point it's realistic to lay more blame on him for the lack of a win than any single other player, including Henne.
 
kud said:
I said this earlier and I agree. Marsh wants a real QB here, he's not trying to hard out there.
Click to expand...

Which is exactly why we need to get rid of him. He plays when he wants to, and takes plays off way too often. And if the ball gets thrown to him, and he doesn't feel like catching it, then he doesn't catch it. He's a cancer, plain and simple.
 
dabeastdabone said:
I doubt he is considered a top 10 WR by anyone other than some Miami fans. A top 10 WR doesn't drop the kind of ball he does. At this point it's realistic to lay more blame on him for the lack of a win than any single other player, including Henne.
Click to expand...
actually I was in another forum and it has all the fans and they voted on him being 6 or 7,so...
 
I didn't like the trade and never will .. Marshall is not Megatron or Andre Johnson, both of whom play hard and are good character guys .. Marshall is too much of a cancer IMHO!!! now add in the fact that Marshall's drops have cost the team ... just like when Joey Porter was brought in .. some guy's i just don't see why .. and both Porter and Marshall were exactly that!!!
 
Marshall has the potential to be there....When were on primetime he seems to be very vocal and plays alot harder.. I expect him to have a big game against the Jests.
 
With the new CBA Marshall isn't even worth a second, nevermind those who are talking a 1st.
 
I'm going to say it right now.. Brandon Marshall is a quitter. He looks like he QUIT on that bomb.. tough catch> sure.. but winners make the play.. they at least TRY! Do you see receivers for Tom Brady being so weak? See where they sent Moss?

I was a huge Marshall fan.. now I see him as a guy stealing money from this franchise, after signing the big contract.

Marshall your a wuss, a quitter, a whiner, a *****.

I hope this is your last season in a dolphin uniform, so that we can field players who give a ****.

**** off Brandon Marshall.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom