No, we were not nearly as bad as our record indicated last season (I don't care about that stupid Parcells saying) and to prove it let me do a recap:
Week 2 at Cincinnati: In spite of a masterful defensive effort by the Dolphins, we still fall 16-13 in the closing seconds to the Bengals.
Key Moments: Anthony Simmons' 51-yard interception return for a touchdown and the questionable decision to switch to a prevent style defense toward the end. Had we taken away the turnovers, we would have won 13-6 in spite of a pitiful offensive showing.
Week 9 vs Arizona: In a battle of two of the NFL's worst teams, the Dolphins lose when Josh McCown culminates a long drive with a 2 yard touchdown pass to Larry Fitzgerald to give the Cardinals a 24-23 win at Dolphins Stadium with 19 seconds left.
Key Plays: This, in my opinion was the worst defeat of the season, AJ Feeley rallied the team to a 23-17 lead with under two minutes to go and thanks to an embarresing defensive collapse and questionable officiating we go down. Had the Dolphins stopped McCown for scrambling for 9 yards on 4th and 8 or had JT's sack in the waning moments counted (thank u Mr. Zebra!), the Dolphins walk away with a 23-17 win.
Week 10 at Seattle: In Jim Bates' head coaching debut, the 1-8 Dolphins give the NFC West leading Seahawks a run for their money, but fall 24-17 when Michael Boulware returns an errant AJ Feeley pass 63 yards for a touchdown.
Key Plays: Toward the end of the half, AJ Feeley had the Dolphins on a rare sustained offensive drive that reached the five yard line. On second down, Feeley zipped an apparent 5-yard scoring pass to Chris Chambers, but an illegal motion penalty negated the score and the next play, Feeley was sacked and fumbled away the oppurtunity. Olindo Mare didn't help matters when his 34-yard field goal attempt drifted wide left in the 4th quarter. Had Miami played smarter football, they might have walked away from the Pacific Northwest with a huge 27-17 upset.
So, from my deduction had the Dolphins played a little smarter and limited the turnovers and penalties, they could have achieved a 7-9 record in 2004, which would be remarkable considering the circumstances they endured over the offseason.