I completely disagree. Those are marginal players you named, other than Charles Clay. I always liked Clay and named him as our most underrated player heading into the season. We finally started using him correctly, simultaneous to the light going on for him and the athletic arrogance returning, the trait he displayed so frequently at Tulsa. Clay won a couple of first half bets for me virtually by himself at Tulsa.
If we overreact and are happy with overmatched players like Carroll and Wilson, it does nothing for this team down the road. Pittsburgh was shredding us last weekend. Every time they threw over the middle we seemed hopeless for the bulk of the game. Fortunately they dropped several of them. This site likes to ignore things like that. They dropped a few early and a couple late. I was very happy when Roethlisberger brainstormed to start targeting LeVeon Bell in the passing game.
Carroll made one of the decisive plays of the game when he dove to deflect the 3rd down pass when we trailed 28-24. That was a long yardage play, after Pittsburgh shot itself in the foot with two unforced penalties, the double clutch by the center followed by the ineligible linemen downfield. Minus either one of those penalties and I'm not sure we stop that drive. Roethlisberger had to force a pass downfield and Carroll displayed tremendous effort. Reshad Jones never would have dove for that play. He doesn't dive for anything.
I give Carroll credit but 3rd and very long plays are supposed to be stopped. Lots of time to react and dive for that ball. He's not the answer in normal situations against top caliber receiver and quarterbacks. Don't make me remind of that down the road. We should acknowledge it now, and not be stupid enough to pretend he magically bloomed.
Players of that caliber get you beat. I still don't see great players out there. Somehow we are giddy at 7-6, with recent wins over sub .500 teams like the Jets and Steelers.
Ireland will probably be content with guys we have, since they are his guys, and doom us to .500 area borderline irrelevancy next season.