Tough choice! Instant reaction is probably Marino if I'm honest, but I voted Don Shula because he built up or built upon everything that makes me proud to be a Dolphins fan. From the winning, to being the least penalized team every year, to being the only team to have an undefeated season, to getting the best out of his players, to winning with class, to winning with defense when he had Arnsparger or running when he had Csonka or passing when he had Marino, to the most wins EVER, to being the highest winningest percentage professional team in any sport once upon a time, Don Shula is the G.O.A.T. He won, with only 2 losing seasons EVER. He did it with style and class, every year. He consistently got the most out of his teams, which rarely were the most talented. Wade Phillips' legendary father, Bum Phillips, once said this about Don Shula:
Don Shula is the legend, and deserves his legendary status. I want all that good stuff again.
"he can take his'uns and beat your'uns, and then turn around and take your'uns and beat his'uns." - Bum Phillips
Don Shula is the legend, and deserves his legendary status. I want all that good stuff again.