When all is said and done, will Jeff Ireland go down as the worst ever gm in Miami? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

When all is said and done, will Jeff Ireland go down as the worst ever gm in Miami?

uga3406

Pro Bowler
Joined
Jan 25, 2006
Messages
3,765
Reaction score
10
Age
52
Location
princeton,nj
We have seen a fair share of awful GM's come thru Miami. What I want to know, when it is all over with, will Ireland go down as the worst ever?
 
Are we the only team who got worse on the outbreak of Free Agency?

2 more giant steps down to the cellar ... Marshall & Soliai

Not negative, just ... I'm expecting signing lower echelon guys like last year ... those remaining after a couple weeks.

Will they RE-peat ... can they THREE-peat ... stay tuned!!
 
My God some people have no memory on this board. I am no Ireland apologist, in fact I had no problem with the thought of firing him at the end of last season, but the man had a pretty decent draft last year. He also has in the past brought some good free agents in Dansby, Wake, and even Incognito has not been to bad. He made what turned out to be a pretty good trade to pick up Reggie Bush last year, and this year he has already signed the best running back from the cfl. If you think for a second that spielman and wanstadt did a better job than ireland, then you are probably part of the group that thinks that matt moore is a quality starter in this league. God help us if this mentality grabs hold of our franchise again. I'm not sure how I feel about the Marshall trade yet, but at least I will let it play out before i pass judgement. Spielman better! you have to be kidding me.
 
We have seen a fair share of awful GM's come thru Miami. What I want to know, when it is all over with, will Ireland go down as the worst ever?

He's right there with Rick Spielman...two mediocre scouts that are in way over their heads.
 
Comparable to Matt Millen? I think so but at lest he liked his Wide Receivers. I think one of the worst in NFL history even if Peyton is signed.
 
My God some people have no memory on this board. I am no Ireland apologist, in fact I had no problem with the thought of firing him at the end of last season, but the man had a pretty decent draft last year. He also has in the past brought some good free agents in Dansby, Wake, and even Incognito has not been to bad. He made what turned out to be a pretty good trade to pick up Reggie Bush last year, and this year he has already signed the best running back from the cfl. If you think for a second that spielman and wanstadt did a better job than ireland, then you are probably part of the group that thinks that matt moore is a quality starter in this league. God help us if this mentality grabs hold of our franchise again. I'm not sure how I feel about the Marshall trade yet, but at least I will let it play out before i pass judgement. Spielman better! you have to be kidding me.

Give me a break.....I am sick of hearing the argument that he had a "pretty decent draft". He picked a frieking center at 15, that is about as safe (and stupid in my mind) as you can possibly get. Daniel Thomas has proven nothing and frankly he has bust written all over him to me. Gates showed nothing, nor will he amount to anything.
 
I just don't see how we can compete with this team.
 
It's getting there. His 'smartest guy in the room' tactics are killing the Dolphins. Not willing to gamble on young QB prospects like a Mallet, instead reaching for the Koa Misi's of the world.

Trading back in the first round, and drafting a 34 DE in Jared Odrick, when you have sh*tload of them already on your roster. And the PR disaster that was the Dez Bryant situation. It's frusturating, all around.
 
Give me a break.....I am sick of hearing the argument that he had a "pretty decent draft". He picked a frieking center at 15, that is about as safe (and stupid in my mind) as you can possibly get. Daniel Thomas has proven nothing and frankly he has bust written all over him to me. Gates showed nothing, nor will he amount to anything.
This.
 
Back
Top Bottom