Why do most Training Camp reports always contradict each other?

[tastes like chi]

don't for a minute think that a newspaper writer has more knowlage than anybody else. They are just better writers that is it. Look at all these guys that make predictions for 2005 most just go off of last year's teams. I will not sit here and tell you that the Dolphins are going to win the superbowl, but this team has made so many positive moves how can you even say(with Knowlage) that they will be last in the east. you can't yet the writers ALL say so.

Please keep all the reports coming. It is good to here any prospective. Thanks to all who take the time and effort to do so.

 

[cnc66]

the "eye witness" least reliable of all. no-one see's the same thing

 

[Ozzy]

It seems like every day you get training camp reports from various users.. One will say, "Feeley was terrible out there, inaccurate and really struggling..", while the other will say "Feeley clearly outplayed Frerotte today, he was accurate all day and had some nice deep balls." :confused:

This happens every year, one reason why I really dont take much stock in them.. Almost every player gets a conflicting view from different users.. Maybe you guys posting TC reports should get together and tell each other which area you will focus on, so you can devote all your time analyzing/watching that position, so that when everyone compiles their specified report it would be more accurate?

I got an answer to that one.

I would actually be worried if everyone wrote the same thing. Why? Because soon everyone would be wearing the exact same outfits, drive the exact same vehicles, have their hair all the same.... :D

Seriously though, everyone has some bias in them, and its going to at some point get in the way with the truth.

There is nothing real conflicting this time around. I like different views myself.

 

[Oboy]

Isn't this why we are all on a message board? To see/hear different opinions?

Anyway, if you think there is too much contradiction just read the papers... or just one particular person's reports!?

Or another thought is if there is that much difference of opinion... only one thing is obvious, for the QB example... NEITHER QB is out-playing the other by that much. Otherwise, everyone would be in agreement.