Would You Welcome Jonathan Martin Back Next Season? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Would You Welcome Jonathan Martin Back Next Season?

Would You Welcome Jonathan Martin Back Next Season?

  • Yes, he was the victim and deserves a second chance

    Votes: 5 1.4%

  • Yes, so long as he first is professionally certified as “safe” and “sober”

    Votes: 15 4.2%

  • No, there’s no place on the team for someone as unhinged and disruptive

    Votes: 194 54.2%

  • No, no matter whatever I think of him, his play is not good enough

    Votes: 144 40.2%
  • Total voters
    358
  • Poll closed .
Not only would I say no to Martin, but the rest of the FA linemen as well.
 
No. He needs a start elsewhere. I think it is time for a new line outside of Pouncey. Garner and Brenner can be nice backups. A flip OT is needed as well.
 
No way.

I can just imagine the harassment he's going to receive from defensive linemen during a game.

They know just how to get under his skin now.
 
Short answer is no, I don't want him ever playing for us under any circumstances.

However, I'm wondering if Martin would even report to camp if he was welcomed back. He's probably too embarrassed. If I am Miami and I cant trade him or get value for him, I'd play hardball with him. If he doesn't report, force him to repay the signing bonus, put him on the non-football injury list, deactivate him, ect.
 
JMart can't be trusted and he handled the whole thing wrong at this point you don't know what his mental state is and can flip-out at anytime. As a player I would be concerned for my safety with him around.
 
not going to even look to see the person that said that a 350 pound football player is a victim..unless he was saying that he was a victim of Suggs treating him like his b#$ch during the ravens game...
 
You know, if he was a first-rate LT, and I could convince myself of his mental fitness, I just might give him another chance. But his overall performance was very mediocre, and even if he was clean and sober, I'm not sure he could ever be any good. Add to that the risks in bringing him back (i.e. the media circus, the locker room dynamics, and what happens if he still sucks and I want to cut him now?), and it's clearly not worth it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom