Athlon Sports ranks the coaches: Wannstedt @ 23..
- Thread starter SkapePhin
- Start date
MOULDSROCKS
☠️ Banned ☠️
19. Davis Cleveland
what the hell!?
what the hell!?
CRAZYDOLFAN305
We Are Still Going To The SB
As much as some you hate Dave, you have to admit this list is FRAUD..
AmishJihad
Bills Motivational Speaker
Well considering that he hasnt been head coach for a single game yet, I find his ranking justified. But then again, why isnt Lovie Smith down there? He aint done jack yet. The funny thing is that they have him ahead of Mooch and Schottzy.Snickersbps said:I dont know guys, they've got Mularke at 32, so it couldnt be THAT bad
nicolosi718
Practice Squad
- Joined
- May 30, 2004
- Messages
- 106
- Reaction score
- 0
Mularkey Buffalo at dead last. I hope he lives up to his billing
Silent Hippy
☠️ Banned ☠️
- Joined
- May 26, 2004
- Messages
- 601
- Reaction score
- 0
he should be ranked last!!!
Fatherof25
☠️ Banned ☠️
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2004
- Messages
- 75
- Reaction score
- 0
- Age
- 38
I agree with the first list except for lubie smith and steve mariucci. They should be way ahead of wanstaad. not below him. MIAMI DOLPHINS NUMBER 1
Pope Shula XIV
EDDSified!
BLITZKRIEG said:That list is a joke....
Dave is better than the following....
#6 - J. Fox - What has he done???...The Panther went to the SB, but his record prior to last season was horrible. Has he really proven himself to be a better HC than Dave??? Just because he took the Panthers to the SB, now he's one of the best HC's in the NFL??? It takes more than one good season to make a good HC IMO. That's all he's had....
#8 - J. Gruden - Yeah, that team looked really strong with the talent HC T. Dungy left him. Won him a SB too. They've become the Bucs of old now, and they look weaker than ever with the big off-season departures. When the Bucs go 7-9 or 6-10 in 2004, you'll understand why he's no better than Wanny....
#9 - J. Gibbs - This guy has been out of football for over a decade!!. Let's see what the Skinz do in 2004 before automatically placing him among the NFL's top 10. He could flop just as easily as Spurrier IMO....
#12 - M. Lewis - :shakeno:
#13 - B. Cowher - About the same. No real proof that Cowher has any edge over Wanny. In fact, considering the divison the Steelers play in, I'd put Wanny ahead of him. How many times have the Steelers had home field advantage thoughout the playoffs, and still fallen short???....Too many. If Dave had those same playoff opportunities in Miami, he'd be wearing a SB ring right now IMO....
#17 - T. Coughlin - No chance. The guy is not that good. He's been struggling to keep a HCing job for years now. He's a good motivator, but not much of a communicator. He's no better than Dave IMO....
#18 - H. Edwards - :roflmao: Yeah, he's done wonders for that Jets defense hasn't he?? Another good motivator, but lacks in other areas. It's clearly showing with the way the Jets have fallen in recent years. If he doesn't have major improvement in 2004, he'll be looking for a new home in 2005...
#19 - B. Davis - No comment needed here other than the guy who made this list is clearly certifiable.... :confused:
#21 - J. Hasslett - Ridiculous. If this guy is better than Dave, why aren't the Saints marching to SB's under him??? This guy is a loose cannon, and very unstable in his job IMO.
#22 - D. Green - Why don't they just put D. Green up next to HC J. Gibbs???...Afterall, neither have proven they can still coach....
This is silly, Detriot's S. Marriucci is an excellent HC, near the top 10 IMO, and he's ranked #26 below Wanny?!?!?! Like I said at the beginning, this is a joke. :roflmao:
PHINZ RULE!! :fire:
Please tell me you're kidding??!! Your statements about John Fox and Jon Gruden are absolutely ludicrous. Fox's quick turnaround in Carolina is a testament to his coaching. He is a true defensive guru (unlike other Miami head coaches that will remian anonymous). Yes, Tampa Bay had a rough year. But do you honestly think that if Wannstedt replaced Dungy instead of Gruden that the Bucs win the Super Bowl??? If you do, then I want some of what you're smoking!
:harm:
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2001
- Messages
- 9,591
- Reaction score
- 1
:roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao:BLITZKRIEG said:That list is a joke....
Dave is better than the following....
#6 - J. Fox - What has he done???...The Panther went to the SB, but his record prior to last season was horrible. Has he really proven himself to be a better HC than Dave??? Just because he took the Panthers to the SB, now he's one of the best HC's in the NFL??? It takes more than one good season to make a good HC IMO. That's all he's had....
#8 - J. Gruden - Yeah, that team looked really strong with the talent HC T. Dungy left him. Won him a SB too. They've become the Bucs of old now, and they look weaker than ever with the big off-season departures. When the Bucs go 7-9 or 6-10 in 2004, you'll understand why he's no better than Wanny....
#9 - J. Gibbs - This guy has been out of football for over a decade!!. Let's see what the Skinz do in 2004 before automatically placing him among the NFL's top 10. He could flop just as easily as Spurrier IMO....
#12 - M. Lewis - :shakeno:
#13 - B. Cowher - About the same. No real proof that Cowher has any edge over Wanny. In fact, considering the divison the Steelers play in, I'd put Wanny ahead of him. How many times have the Steelers had home field advantage thoughout the playoffs, and still fallen short???....Too many. If Dave had those same playoff opportunities in Miami, he'd be wearing a SB ring right now IMO....
#17 - T. Coughlin - No chance. The guy is not that good. He's been struggling to keep a HCing job for years now. He's a good motivator, but not much of a communicator. He's no better than Dave IMO....
#18 - H. Edwards - :roflmao: Yeah, he's done wonders for that Jets defense hasn't he?? Another good motivator, but lacks in other areas. It's clearly showing with the way the Jets have fallen in recent years. If he doesn't have major improvement in 2004, he'll be looking for a new home in 2005...
#19 - B. Davis - No comment needed here other than the guy who made this list is clearly certifiable.... :confused:
#21 - J. Hasslett - Ridiculous. If this guy is better than Dave, why aren't the Saints marching to SB's under him??? This guy is a loose cannon, and very unstable in his job IMO.
#22 - D. Green - Why don't they just put D. Green up next to HC J. Gibbs???...Afterall, neither have proven they can still coach....
This is silly, Detriot's S. Marriucci is an excellent HC, near the top 10 IMO, and he's ranked #26 below Wanny?!?!?! Like I said at the beginning, this is a joke. :roflmao:
PHINZ RULE!! :fire:
SkapePhin said:
I would also add that here is no way that Edwards is ahead of Wannstedt. They are both pretty much in the same scale as far as coaches, but I still give give Wanny an edge, as far as being better at getting talent, and game planning. It's being a game day coach, where he falls apart.
Theres at least 5 or 6 of the one's ranked below him that I would take over him this year, but clearly he is considered in the bottom feeder class of NFL head coaches, a coordinator miscast as a head man.SkapePhin said:
ESPN I think it was ranked him 110th out of 120 coaches in the major sports..........not surprising
Rick 1966
Professional Hipshooter
As much as I lack respect for Wanny's coaching ability, I do have to say that this list is a joke.
Well lets see, for starters he got his team into the playoffs last year, Wanny last accomplished that feat three years ago.LIQUID24 said:
Oh, and he also was a good enough coach to not waste more than four years on his mediocre quarterback despite a Pro Bowl year, Wanny of course is going into year five of the Jay Fiedler experiment (not to mention Wanny picked up Shanny's scraps after he flopped)