I saw that also. I'll take CK's opinion over Kelly's every time.
Omar Kelly: The under-qualified Helen Keller of observation and communication.
I saw that also. I'll take CK's opinion over Kelly's every time.
One place was when Omar basically tweeted that on day one of OTA's as if that was already decided on what he saw day 1. I will pass on Omar's judgment of QB's and wait to see more.
I've had this disagreement with Omar before. I respect being confident in yourself and your opinions, but in this case I would consider it to be more stubbornness. He's convinced you can't judge arm strength unless you see it live. That would probably be true in the most traditional sense, because apparently nobody's ever thought to actually measure average velocity on throws. If you're just eyeballing it then I suspect being on the field gives you a better feel than seeing it on video.
But the simple fact of the matter is these throws are recorded on video and the technology does exist to allow us to break that video down and extract average velocities. It can be done. It's not some strange hocum. I've been doing it in one manner or another since the Dolphins traded for A.J. Feeley in 2004.
I think Omar has a tendency, like most people to be honest, to take a position and then entrench himself. He didn't see a strong arm on video and so it's unsurprising he doesn't see a strong arm live. I can't speak for what he's seeing live in practices. I'm not there. But I can speak for individual throws he saw on video, throws that he and I have isolated and discussed. His eyeball perceptions told him that those throws weren't impressive, for one reason or another. But the numbers tell a much different story on those throws. If his perceptions of the throws on video can end up so contrary to the numbers then it makes me think his perceptions even live in practice can run contrary to the numbers. And when it comes to arm strength, velocity is velocity. It's a tangible, measurable quality.
I would venture to guess that it will not take the coaches too long of a time to judge if he does or does not have what they determine to be an NFL quality arm etc. If not he will be released like Rodgers was IMO.
Where is the "weak arm" stuff coming from?
This is not a weak-armed throw (fast-foward to 0:08:56 if the link doesn't work right):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YPwD...tailpage#t=536
Nor is this a weak-armed throw (fast-foward to 5:14 if the link doesn't work right):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2vMt...tailpage#t=314
This throw is not on target, but it's hardly a weak-armed throw either (0:39:28):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...DGinY6I#t=2368
People have these preconceived notions about what type of prospect this guy is or that guy. They know Brock Jensen is a small school winner with good stats and decent but not great size, so they assume he must have a weak arm. Then they see a weak arm even when high velocity throws are staring them in the face.
The guy isn't exactly Jamarcus Russell but to say he's got a weak arm is just not accurate.
Where is the "weak arm" stuff coming from?
This is not a weak-armed throw (fast-foward to 0:08:56 if the link doesn't work right):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YPwDGinY6I&feature=player_detailpage#t=536
Nor is this a weak-armed throw (fast-foward to 5:14 if the link doesn't work right):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2vMtL1GwHw&feature=player_detailpage#t=314
This throw is not on target, but it's hardly a weak-armed throw either (0:39:28):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=6YPwDGinY6I#t=2368
People have these preconceived notions about what type of prospect this guy is or that guy. They know Brock Jensen is a small school winner with good stats and decent but not great size, so they assume he must have a weak arm. Then they see a weak arm even when high velocity throws are staring them in the face.
The guy isn't exactly Jamarcus Russell but to say he's got a weak arm is just not accurate.
Where is the "weak arm" stuff coming from?
This is not a weak-armed throw (fast-foward to 0:08:56 if the link doesn't work right):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YPwDGinY6I&feature=player_detailpage#t=536
Nor is this a weak-armed throw (fast-foward to 5:14 if the link doesn't work right):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2vMtL1GwHw&feature=player_detailpage#t=314
This throw is not on target, but it's hardly a weak-armed throw either (0:39:28):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=6YPwDGinY6I#t=2368
People have these preconceived notions about what type of prospect this guy is or that guy. They know Brock Jensen is a small school winner with good stats and decent but not great size, so they assume he must have a weak arm. Then they see a weak arm even when high velocity throws are staring them in the face.
The guy isn't exactly Jamarcus Russell but to say he's got a weak arm is just not accurate.