Dol-Fan Dupree
Manning to Tyree = Best SB Play EVER!!!!
CirclingWagons said:Elway is a ahead of Marino on that list for 2 reasons...
Well neither of them can be superbowl, because that would be stupid.
CirclingWagons said:Elway is a ahead of Marino on that list for 2 reasons...
There might be a few Giants' fans who would disagree. Remember Sehorn letting ..what was it...three? ...touchdowns go down while he was lagging back there somewhere instead of giving the coverage he had become known for. (granted, he had been injured and has never really overcome that knee problem)MDFINFAN said:By the same token, one player can't lose a SB for you..ie. Jay Fielder...but if you read this board, your theory has no ground to stand on..
according to YOU.Dol-Fan Dupree said:Well neither of them can be superbowl, because that would be stupid.
fin-atic said:CW
Who was the better running back Barry Sanders or Antwoin Smith?
Smith is accordign to your philosophy because Barry has no ring.
That also makes Dilfer better than:
Marino
Fouts
Peyton Manning
McNabb
SB is about team. Thats why Marino didn't win one because the team wasn't good enough, it was why Elway failed for many years ebcause the team was not good enough, and it is why Dilfer did win is because the team was good enough.
fin-atic said:As far as Elway goes. who says running is the deciding factor? The other skills Dan has are enough superior that it out weighs the running element. Especially when you consider the value of the various skills to the position. Running is the least valuabel to the QB job.
Hellion said:You just backed up my arguement, thanks.
That's why Marino is a better QB.
It's hillarious, I write, "Elway is a better athlete" and what people read is, "Elway is a better QB" and that's all they see.
The question that TT put up was "Top 25 ATHLETES" not football players, not QBs, but athletes in general, there wasn't a link provided so I assumed he meant overall ATHLETE.
And in my opinion Elway is more athletic, Not a better QB.
MDFINFAN said:By the same token, one player can't lose a SB for you..ie. Jay Fielder...but if you read this board, your theory has no ground to stand on..
juniorseau55 said:That list is horribly composed.... its mostly based on achievements...
CirclingWagons said:Elway is a ahead of Marino on that list for 2 reasons...
Marino was better than elway, elway was just on a better team! Elway played one more year than dan, and he still isnt close to having the alltime yards record in a career, marino has many records that may never be broken.dolphan39 said:they mean player. Ridiculous to say Elway is better than Dan because his teams were better, but we've been there b4
I cannot find link anywhere http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/espn25/index