Who is your top 10 RB's? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Who is your top 10 RB's?

zach8111

zach8111

Pro Bowler
Joined
Mar 20, 2007
Messages
3,448
Reaction score
16
Location
Fremont, Ohio
Who do you think is the top 10 RB's in the league right now?
mine are:

1- Ladanian Tomlinson SD-Best All around back
2-Adrian Peterson Minn-Really young but very good runner and catching but great o-line help out a lot
3-Brian Westbrook Phil-one of the best all around backs; does it all very well
4-Larry Johnson KC-when healthy he is a monster and can carry 350 times a year
5-Steven Jacksin Stl-very powerful RB and good runner
6-Ronnie Brown MIA-when healthy he is a beast behind a poor o-line.
7-Clinton Portis Wash-great all around back, good runner
8-Willie Parker Pitt-very fast and a good runner and at catching
9-Frank Gore SF-good fast back who emerged two years ago as a top back in the league
10-Willis McGahee BAL-good when healthy
 
Ummmm.... Brown, Brown, Brown, Brown, Brown, Brown, Brown, Brown, Brown, and Brown. :)
 
1. Adrian Peterson
2. LT
3. Willie Parker
4. Joseph Addai
5. B. Westbrooke
6. Ronnie Brown :)
7. Freddy Taylor
8. Steven Jackson
9. Frank Gore
10. Marion Barber
 
1- Ladanian Tomlinson SD
2-Steven Jacksin Stl
3-Adrian Peterson Minn
4-Clinton Portis Wash
5-Larry Johnson KC
6-Frank Gore SF
7-Brian Westbrook Phil
8-Shaun Alexander Sea
9-Willie Parker Pitt
10-Fred Taylor Jack

My take
 
1. LT
2. AD
3. Steven Jackson
4. Ronnie Brown
5. Shaun Alexander
6. Larry Johnson
7. Willis Mcgahee
8. Frank Gore
9. myrshawn lynch
10. Clinton Portis

I might have forgot someone tho
 
I am ok with some people not thinking RB is in the top 10, but you guys really can't think Alexander is?
 
Not in really any order but....

1. LT
2. Maurice Jones Drew
3. Willie Parker
4. Larry Johnson
5. Ronnie Brown
6. Clinton Portis
7. Adrian Peterson
8. Chester Taylor
9. Deuce Mcallister
10. Stephen Jackson

Notice no Reggie Bush?:up:
 
1- LT
2- Peterson
3- S JAX
4- Westbrook
5- Parker
6- Brown
7- LJ -just an off year
8- addai
9- Portis
10 - barber

really wanted to put lynch in there though
 
1. LaDanian Tomlinson
2. Brian Westbrook
3. Adrian Peterson
4. Ronnie Brown
5. Willie Parker
6. Steven Jackson
7. Larry Johnson
8. Clinton Portis
9. Willis McGahee
10. Marion Barber
 
Enforcerfin33 said:
Not in really any order but....

1. LT
2. Maurice Jones Drew
3. Willie Parker
4. Larry Johnson
5. Ronnie Brown
6. Clinton Portis
7. Adrian Peterson
8. Chester Taylor
9. Deuce Mcallister
10. Stephen Jackson

Notice no Reggie Bush?:up:
Click to expand...

Really disagree with Mccallister and Taylor(though I like him a lot). How do you not have Brian Westbrook?
 
Stitches said:
Really disagree with Mccallister and Taylor(though I like him a lot). How do you not have Brian Westbrook?
Click to expand...

I actually forgot about him honestly. He is one of the top 5...so that would eliminate Duece. I stand by Taylor, I think on a one back team hes a pro bowler.
 
Enforcerfin33 said:
I actually forgot about him honestly. He is one of the top 5...so that would eliminate Duece. I stand by Taylor, I think on a one back team hes a pro bowler.
Click to expand...

I love taylor, I got to watch him all through college and in his record setting bowl performance as a senior. I just think Mcgahee and F. Taylor are better is all. Personally, I would prefer Chester over Willie Parker because I think he is more well rounded.
 
L.T.
B. Westbrook
S. Jackson
F. Gore
B. Jacobs
A. Peterson
C. Portis
W. Parker
M. Lynch
R. Brown

you know i had to throw in lynch :up:

Duece and Addai are good Rbs but hyped up beyond thier skill.
I wanted to put McGahee in instead of Brown, but **** McGahee. If you hit his legs he cant do anything.
 
I really hate when I see Joseph Addai in top 10's, running in Indianapolis is becoming like running in Denver, any one can do it. Edgerin James was great there, Dominic Rhodes was good, and when Addai went down this season, Kenton Keith was very good.

What I did was type out the running backs I thought should be considered. 13 guys came out and here is how I ranked them. I took every aspect of being a running back into consideration, not just running (which is why Portis made the list.)

1. LaDainian Tomlinson
2. Adrian Peterson
3. Brian Westbrook
4. Ronnie Brown
5. Steven Jackson
6. Willie Parker
7. Maurice Jones-Drew
8. Marion Barber
9. Fred Taylor
10. Willis McGahee

11. Larry Johnson
12. Marshawn Lynch
13. Clinton Portis
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom