2018 Qbs: Production Analysis | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

2018 Qbs: Production Analysis

Mike Kafka

DATA:

Com: 319
Att: 492 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 64.8 (clears the benchmark, over 63)
TD: 16
INT: 12
SK: 26

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 18.9 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 41.0 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 30.8 (Red flag, way over 16)
Reliability: 16.4 (Red flag way under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable, he has two big red flags.
 
John Skelton

DATA:

Com: 284
Att: 441 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 64.4 (clears the benchmark, over 63)
TD: 26
INT: 10
SK: 28

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 15.6 (Red flag, under 17)
Att/int: 44.1 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 17.0 (Red flag, over 16)
Reliability: 25.07 (Red flag, under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB has too many flags and is not draftable.
 
Rusty Smith

DATA:

Com: 234
Att: 435 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 53.8 (Red flag, under 61)
TD: 24
INT: 14
SK: 16

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 27.2 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 31.1 (Red flag, under 35.8)
Att/TD: 18.1 (Red flag, over 16)
Reliability: 25.1 (Red flag, under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many red flags.
 
Joe Webb

DATA:

Com: 162
Att: 271 (Red flag, under 280)
C%: 59.8 (Red flag, under 61)
TD: 21
INT: 8
SK: 21

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 12.9 (Red flag under 17)
Att/int: 33.9 (Red flag, under 35.8)
Att/TD: 12.9 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 20.3 (Red flag under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many red flags.
 
Cam Newton

DATA:

Com: 185
Att: 280 (Yellow flag 280-350)
C%: 66.07 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 30
INT: 7
SK: 23

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 12.2 (Red flag, under 17)
Att/int: 40 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 9.3 (Green flag, under 10.5)
Reliability: 34.5 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)
Additional: National Champ, Green flag

Conclusion: This Qb is draftable, first rd value. He can overcome red flag with green flag, and while the attempts are low he has the frame, strength, and arm to produce more. He is a National Champ.
 
Jake Locker

DATA:

Com: 184
Att: 332 (Yellow flag 280 - 350)
C%: 55.4 (Red flag, under 61)
TD: 17
INT: 9
SK: 19

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 17.5 (Yellow flag, 17-17.89)
Att/int: 36.9 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 19.5 (Red flag, over 16)
Reliability: 18.3 (Red flag, under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many bad flags.
 
Blaine Gabbert

DATA:

Com: 301
Att: 475 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 63.4 (clears the benchmark, over 63)
TD: 16
INT: 9
SK: 22

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 21.6 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 52.8 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 29.7 (Red flag, way over 16)
Reliability: 24.3 (Red flag, under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of the two red flags.
 
Christian Ponder

DATA:

Com: 184
Att: 299 (Yellow flag, 280 - 350)
C%: 61.5 (Yellow flag, over 61-63)
TD: 20
INT: 8
SK: 23

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 13.0 (Red flag, under 17)
Att/int: 37.4 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 15.0 (Yellow flag, 14-16)
Reliability: 20.0 (Red flag, under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many bad flags.
 
Andy Dalton

DATA:

Com: 209
Att: 316 (Yellow flag, 280 - 350)
C%: 66.1 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 27
INT: 6
SK: 8

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 39.5 (Green flag, over 34)
Att/int: 52.7 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 11.7 (clears the benchmark, 10.5-14)
Reliability: 117.6 (Red flag on the dot, just over 117)

Conclusion: This QB is a judgment call. Yellow flag can be overcome by green flag, and then he has elite numbers, but the reliability is on the dot, borderline. I would not draft him.
 
Colin Kapernick

DATA:

Com: 233
Att: 359 (clears the benchmark over 350)
C%: 64.9 (clears the benchmark, over 63)
TD: 21
INT: 8
SK: 10

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 35.9 (Green flag, over 34)
Att/int: 44.9 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 17.1 (Red flag, over 16)
Reliability: 61.2 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is draftable. Red flag can be overcome by green flag. Low scoring concerns me so I would give him a mid round grade.
 
Ryan Mallett

DATA:

Com: 266
Att: 411 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 64.7 (clears the benchmark, over 63)
TD: 32
INT: 12
SK: 25

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 16.4 (Red flag not under 17)
Att/int: 34.3 (Yellow flag, 34 - 35.8)
Att/TD: 12.8 (clears the benchmark, 10.5-14)
Reliability: 28.37 (Red flag, under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many bad flags.
 
Tyrod Taylor

DATA:

Com: 188
Att: 315 (Yellow flag 280 - 350)
C%: 59.7 (Red flag under 61)
TD: 24
INT: 5
SK: 34

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 9.3 (Red flag under 17)
Att/int: 63.0 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 13.1 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 26.5 (Red flag under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many bad flags.
 
Andrew Luck

DATA:

Com: 288
Att: 404 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 71.3 (Red flag, over 67.5)
TD: 37
INT: 10
SK: 11

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 36.7 (Green flag, over 34)
Att/int: 40.4 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 10.9 (clears the benchmark, 10.5 - 14, close to elite)
Reliability: 96.9 (Yellow flag, 70-117)

Conclusion: This QB is draftable. Green flag overcomes the red flag, and scoring is borderline elite even tho reliability is little high. It all balances out. Scoring is really good, so first round.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom