Comparing David Boston to other WR's

[ρħϊηάτϊς°³]

:roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao:

But in all seriousness and I know this is COMPLETELY off subject but damn Niagra Falls is AWESOME.

Too bad it is the Canadian side which is sweet, the American side has a casino and a bunch of empty buildings, oh but it does have one ****ty aquarium lol

 

[Boik14]

Plummer has had a 4000 yard season. Fiedler, Lucas, Rosenfels, (Brian) Griese, Feeley, Shane Matthews, Jim Miller, Henry Burris, Chris Chandler, Cory Sauter, Rex Grossman, Cade McNown, and Kordell Stewart never have. I believe that's the exhaustive list of QBs Chambers and Booker have played with, btw.

That brings up another point -- in 2001 when Boston had his monster year, Plummer threw EVERY pass. Neither Booker nor Chambers have had that stability over a season at any point in their career. That's huge.

As to Boston being all of Arizona's offense, it hurts the case for Chambers. It really doesn't for Booker. Des White and Anthony Thomas in 2002 for the Bears are equivalent to the duo of Frank Sanders and Michael Pittman in 2001 for the Cardinals.

Im not disputing the list of qb's that Booker and CC have played with in the past and I know that Plummer was Dbo's qb during his great year. Point is Jake the Fake aint done poop since then. Hes a good qb statwise but when you watch him play hes just a stupid qb who makes an buttload of mistakes a la certain qbs on our roster whos names I wont mention to avoid starting more BS about that.

 

[dominizzo]

welllwe need parsyy to see the post so he can kepp his mouth shut

 

[PHINZONER]

Physically:
Power #1
Speed top 5 (@257lbs rand 4.4/40 @235 ran 4.2 and occasional sub 4.2)
Blocking top 5
Hands (?) has shown top 10
Routes (?)
Work Ethic #1 (works out like 3 times a day)(maybe #2 behind Jerry)
Attitude bad at times great at times
$$$$ #1 (talent per $)cheapest probowler& he's 26 not 36/talent left
Overall Top 2-3 Talent and could be a top 5 WR

 

[Oboy]

Sorry I am not going to read all the replies...

I don't think too many people are questioning what Boston CAN do on the field. The big questions are...

Can he get on the field (stay healthy)?
Can he not become a cancer in the locker room?
Can he stay out of trouble off the field?

Those are the big questions and knocks on Boston. To me the second one is the biggest. He signed for minimal $$ so if he is not healthy, it does not cost us much. However, if he becomes a cancer to the team... well that hurts more than anything in today's nfl.

 

[Jimmy James]

Im not disputing the list of qb's that Booker and CC have played with in the past and I know that Plummer was Dbo's qb during his great year. Point is Jake the Fake aint done poop since then. Hes a good qb statwise but when you watch him play hes just a stupid qb who makes an buttload of mistakes a la certain qbs on our roster whos names I wont mention to avoid starting more BS about that.

If this weren't a thread about stats, I'd agree with you. We're arguing stats, though. Plummer looks better on paper than he is (the anti-Aikman), and that rubs off on the other offensive players he played with.