mandal24
Genesis
- Joined
- May 5, 2007
- Messages
- 6,595
- Reaction score
- 7,911
Live in your delusion? LolYeah, or what?
Gimme Derek Carr. Dude plays entire seasons and he can be had. Grier is incapable of getting a decent backup
Dead Serious: What options do we have next year (At QB)?
- Thread starter mandal24
- Start date
Gimme Derek Carr. Dude plays entire seasons and he can be had. Grier is incapable of getting a decent backup
mandal24
Genesis
- Joined
- May 5, 2007
- Messages
- 6,595
- Reaction score
- 7,911
100% agreed. I might even bump Carr up a tier (heās younger and will definitely be available)
On this team, he easily gets 4K yards and 30 TDS and most importantly, will play an entire season
And Iād add Jordan love to tier 3. GB might have some drama this off-season
Dude wants Derek Carr lmaooLive in your delusion? Lol
Gimme Derek Carr. Dude plays entire seasons and he can be had. Grier is incapable of getting a decent backup
Same guy that had Devante Adams, Derek Waller, Josh Jacobs AND still got his ass benched.
Tua is a better QB. Plain and simple.
winnyason
Active Roster
For me it's Tua or Brady.
mandal24
Genesis
- Joined
- May 5, 2007
- Messages
- 6,595
- Reaction score
- 7,911
I wonāt argue that Tua isnāt better but Tua isnāt available for half the season (whether heās injured, or goes through mental meltdowns)
Carr plays entire seasons year after year and puts up solid numbers, despite playing with really bad defenses
Do I love Carr? No. But what other options do we have?
But but this system is QB friendly we can plug and play anyone, Tua sucks.
goes to show how good Tua is. This team is HOT garbage with out him.
Jimmy G is not gonna play like a SF QB in Miami, he's gonna play like teddy and Brissette.
Carr had just as talented offense (if not more) and produced a lot less than Tua.
Tua is the QB we just need a capable back up.
goes to show how good Tua is. This team is HOT garbage with out him.
Jimmy G is not gonna play like a SF QB in Miami, he's gonna play like teddy and Brissette.
Carr had just as talented offense (if not more) and produced a lot less than Tua.
Tua is the QB we just need a capable back up.
You give Tua another off-season to improve on his areas of weakness and run it back with him at the helm. The guy still posted a 25/8 statline and a 8-4 record in this 3rd year.
There really isn't another viable option. Derek Carr is literally a downgrade.
Sticky Gloves
Active Roster
How does Tua improve on not hitting his head and getting concussions? Or not injuring himself like he has in previous seasons with his hip, ankles, thumb, ect...
I don't think these are things Tua can work on in the offseason. He can't stay healthy a full season going back to college.
mandal24
Genesis
- Joined
- May 5, 2007
- Messages
- 6,595
- Reaction score
- 7,911
You canāt improve durability. Tua has been injured since college. There are just those guys that get hurt, and some that donāt.
Unfortunately Tua is one of the most injury-prone nfl players while guys like Carr never miss time.
Carr has a stronger arm, has more āescape-abilityā (spelling??) but less accurate.
Going from Tua to Carr IMO is neutral. Pros and cons to each.
But Carr, with that arm to waddle/hill could be amazing. Carr likes to take chances downfield
Right. Letās go get the 47 year old qb.Rofl