Dolphin Madden 2005 Ratings: You decide | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Dolphin Madden 2005 Ratings: You decide

SkapePhin

SkapePhin

☠️ Banned ☠️
Joined
May 20, 2002
Messages
43,878
Reaction score
12,956
Since it is so boring right now why not give our starting roster Madden 2005 ratings..

Here is mine.

OverallL 88



7 A.J. Feeley: 80
9 Jay Fiedler: 80

34 Ricky Williams: 97

44 Rob Konrad: 89

80 David Boston: 91
84 Chris Chambers: 92

81 Randy McMichael: 89

68 Seth McKinney: 78
74 Wade Smith :77
78 Jeno James : 84
St. Clair: 72
McIntosh: (will be injured in the game)

64 Larry Chester: 90
95 Tim Bowens: 94

93 Adewale Ogunleye: 95
99 Jason Taylor: 97

54 Zach Thoma: 95
55 Junior Seau: 90
52 Morlon Greenwood: 86

23 Patrick Surtain CB: 98
25 Reggie Howard: 88
29 Sam Madison:94



20 Arturo Freeman: 82
24 Sammy Knight : 88

Special Teams:

1 Matt Turk: 90
10 Olindo Mare: 91

Here is a pic of 2005 so you guys can see the graphical improvements:

clear.gif
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We've hit bottom.

Please baby Jesus, bring the Draft.
 
You overrated some of these guys. Their even higher than they are on the online roster.
God we are pathetic.

7 A.J. Feeley: 80
9 Jay Fiedler: 80

34 Ricky Williams: 95

44 Rob Konrad: 85

80 David Boston: 88
84 Chris Chambers: 88

81 Randy McMichael: 89

68 Seth McKinney: 78
74 Wade Smith :77
78 Jeno James : 84
St. Clair: 72
McIntosh: (will be injured in the game)

64 Larry Chester: 87
95 Tim Bowens: 90

93 Adewale Ogunleye: 95
99 Jason Taylor: 97

54 Zach Thoma: 95
55 Junior Seau: 87
52 Morlon Greenwood: 80

23 Patrick Surtain CB: 98
25 Reggie Howard: 88
29 Sam Madison:92



20 Arturo Freeman: 80
24 Sammy Knight : 85

Special Teams:

1 Matt Turk: 83
10 Olindo Mare: 88
 
LOL.. Hey.. At least its constructive.. :p
 
Atila.. I dont think so.. Tiburon always gives the Dolphins good ratings since most of them comprise of Phin or Bucc fans..
 
saves' might be closer.. I now realize Chambers most likely wont start at a 92.. I play Franchise too much.. these are they ratings they are normaly at when I make it deep into the playoffs..
 
7 A.J. Feeley: 70
9 Jay Fiedler: 76

34 Ricky Williams: 95

44 Rob Konrad: 85

80 David Boston: 91
84 Chris Chambers: 89

81 Randy McMichael: 88

68 Seth McKinney: 76
74 Wade Smith :79
78 Jeno James : 84
St. Clair: 72
McIntosh: 77

64 Larry Chester: 86
95 Tim Bowens: 88

93 Adewale Ogunleye: 92
99 Jason Taylor: 98

54 Zach Thoma: 94
55 Junior Seau: 85
52 Morlon Greenwood: 78

23 Patrick Surtain CB: 98
25 Reggie Howard: 85
29 Sam Madison:91



20 Arturo Freeman: 67
24 Sammy Knight : 86

Special Teams:

1 Matt Turk: 83
10 Olindo Mare: 87
 
Inexpierence-this guy was a backup in Philly and college(Oregon?).
 
I'm not saying the guy is going to completely suck this year but if I were working on the game, I wouldn't give a 75 rating to a guy whose never started half a season, let alone a full one. Keep in mind, top rookies usually don't get high ratings on the game.
 
but baccarat.. he will be starter.. Madden rarely make the starting qbs rated lower than a 75... and they cant have Fiedler a backup rated higher.. Fiedler and Feely will have the same rating..
 
Originally posted by baccarat
I'm not saying the guy is going to completely suck this year but if I were working on the game, I wouldn't give a 75 rating to a guy whose never started half a season, let alone a full one. Keep in mind, top rookies usually don't get high ratings on the game.
Click to expand...
I was just teasing but I think starters (I hope he starts) by default get at least a 75 right? I could be wrong....
 
kills me, I think we're always underrated.

But chambers won't be above a low 80's, Ricky will fall a bit, low 90's maybe, McMichael was alwasy underrated and did nothing to gain at all, Mare will go a down a bit, and you can bank on feeley and Fiedler being mid 70's IMO. 80's would be a huge push. O-gun however should be rated higher.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom