hey buddy, if u dont think eli is an elite qb by now, something is wrong with you. My guess is, jets fan jealousy of there big brother giants success. When was the last time the jets won a SB title? 40 years ago??? the giants have won 2 in the last decade buddy.
The last time we won a SB was around the same time Miami last won one.
Jealousy? I'm absolutely jealous of the Giants winning SBs, that's what I want my team to do but I actually really like Eli so it's not jealousy it's reality. A guy w/ zero elite full seasons cannot be elite. Elite postseason player? I could buy that but just a year ago he was coming off a 25 INT season, he led the Giants to 9 wins- he's not elite yet.