Frerotte vs Feeley Who should start???

[Dr. Zoidberg]

Frerotte vs Feeley Who should start next week???

________Yds _Att__ Cmp_TDs_Ints
Frerotte_384__ 74___33__ 1____1


______Yds_Att_Cmp_TDs_Ints
Feeley_280_54__34__ 1___1

Who do you think should start and why? Poll

 

[Dudeman]

next week? AJ....then go from there

 

[MDFINFAN]

next week? AJ....then go from there

I agree, but it does seem who ever we give the keys too, they seem to go bust. Maybe AJ will keep his edge this time.

 

[Maynard the Hammer]

i like being fickle so i'll vote Feeley :D

seriously, though. his deep throws were not even close and he wasnt hurried that many times either. i never got the impression that he under constant duress.

If he can settle down a bit, this team can score some points. we could have scored 3 TDs in the first half pretty easily.

 

[ohall]

C) dunno!

 

[Oregonfinfan]

when this thread is a few days old i want it next to the poll from even last week where it was like 65 -35 for gus!

 

[Maynard the Hammer]

D) can we just skip to next season?

 

[PerfectSZN]

C) dunno!

Sure hope this isn't what Saban's final answer is :goof:

 

[Caps]

I'll go Feeley for now, by default. And it hurts me to say that.

 

[Daytona Fin]

D) can we just skip to next season?

way to keep the spirits high. :shakeno:

 

[jmm13-54]

next week? AJ....then go from there

I agree completely...AJ earned a chance to start with the 1st team next week...if he proves he can run the 1st team too then he's the man...if he doesn't...

:confused:

 

[stilloldduck]

________Yds _Att__ Cmp_TDs_Ints
Frerotte_384__ 58___33__ 1____1


______Yds_Att_Cmp_TDs_Ints
Feeley_280_54__34__ 1___1

Who do you think should start and why? Poll

Sorry, Good Doctor, but your figures aren't right according to NFL.com. They show:

Gus is 33/74 (44%) for 386 yards 1TD 1int

AJ is 34/54 (63%) for 280 yards 1TD 1int

Both players have been victimized by drops so I doubt that skews the completion percentage significantly.

Judging by these figures, the amount he could be expected to improve as he learns Linehan's system better and what I know of AJ, I would not hesitate at all to start AJ each and every game he is physically able to perform.

 

[Jimmy James]

E) Nick has to choose, and I don't envy him the choice.

 

[ohall]

Sure hope this isn't what Saban's final answer is :goof:

I would take a guess here and say the players trust for whichever QB will determine who will be the starter.

At this point I'd have to guess that would be Gus.

 

[vt_dolfan]

I agree next week...but unless Im crazy..dont most teams sit their 1st team the majority of the last game.

I think Saban's mind should have been decided by now IMO.

More upside----Feeley


More improvement over pre season --- Feeley

Better game in week 3..where most gameplanning took place---Feeley.

It really makes no sense to me to start Gus. Feeley has shown he can learn a new offense...and play as good..if not better than someone who has known this offense for years.

Gus would be the perfect B/U as he could really help AJ on the sideline.

Feeley must start week 1. Will he? Only Saban knows that answer.