Why is it that Hurricanes can have a winning team and the fans don't show up? Other major schools are jam packing their stadiums even when they're not winning. What's the excuse?
These are just my opinions
1. Miami plays in a big city as compared to some programs who play in "college towns", and the big city that Miami plays in there's a high number of residents who have no substantial ties to the region since they moved here from somewhere else.
2. Those college towns are usually public universities where everyone in the town has some kind of personal connection to the school whether it be as a student, alumni, faculty, grew up there etc. Miami on the other hand is a small, private university that makes up less than a percent of the town/region.
3. Considering 1,2 that means almost all of Miami's potential fanbase really has no personal connection to the university compared to other schools such as FSU and UF (not necessarily arguing these two have "better fans"). These people simply just will not show up if the product isn't fantastic.
4. Miami's sports fans are extremely fair weathered. Just look at Game 6 of the 2013 NBA finals if you need a reference.
5. Considering 1-4, UM football might as well just be considered a professional sports team in the eyes of Miami fans
6. If you don't win in Miami, they don't show up and sometimes when they get too comfortable with you winning they have a hard time filling up every game (like the Heat). I don't necessarily know how it works in other cities, but ive lived here all my life except for 4 years of college and i know that's how it works in Miami. Spending energy trying to change sports fans' attitudes in this area is like trying to count to infinity; you're wasting your time.
In Conclusion, an extremely accurate Miami equation reads More Wins= More People
I'm not to too big on blaming fans in the entertainment industry. If there's a bad relationship between the producer and consumer in entertainment, I believe it's the producers fault every time. The producer is the one that needs to entice the consumer, not the other way around. Miami is and always will have the potential to be a huge money market for a professional team, it's the job of that team to get fans in the venue.