NYC#1finsfan
Active Roster
With our anemic line and two solid defenders how does our F.O. Not bring these guys back????? Seems unimaginable..
Karras, Van Noy, Godcheux, how do we let them walk?
- Thread starter NYC#1finsfan
- Start date
Our Defense is fine without Noy and Godcheux. Did Karras want to stay? It was a one year deal and I read Miami waited too long and Karras opted to go back to the team that drafted him. Karras didn't exactly have a good season at Centre as a Dolphin anyway which is probably why they delayed on a new deal.
- Joined
- Sep 6, 2019
- Messages
- 22,966
- Reaction score
- 117,769
- Location
- you tell me and we will both know
Wonder how much playing time Phillips would get if was Van Noy taking one of the LB spots?
Has Davis taken Godcheux spot?
Is Dieter a upgrade on Karras at C?
Has Davis taken Godcheux spot?
Is Dieter a upgrade on Karras at C?
KVN was the one I didn’t get.
Poor coaching on the defensive side?.....NO
He got overpaid here. Yes that's on the FO but he under performed for that money.
- Joined
- May 12, 2006
- Messages
- 4,672
- Reaction score
- 6,794
Kara’s and Flowers neither one was expensive, van Noi at least was expensive, but yeah it’s a head scratcher…
- Joined
- May 18, 2003
- Messages
- 3,269
- Reaction score
- 4,245
They we’re short term bridging actions until the draft pick were projected to be ready. With the exception of center (which still might be) they have filled each position with an improvement .
I say yes. They were comfortably 32nd in the league in many categories after the first 8 games. The players complain about the scheme and assignments and BOOM...back to a shut-down defense causing havoc.
Michael Scott
Club Member
KVN is what made no sense, especially after cutting McKinney.
Money
Godchaux would have wanted too much money for what he brings to the table, plus I don't think he was the best scheme fit(from what I've read)
Van Noy was curious, but glad to see Phillips making him forgettable.
Karras was a one year guy to bridge for Dieter; now, we have to see if Dieter can hammer down the spot.
I think a lot of those 2020 FA's were "sign because we had to fill cap space" guys, with no long term intentions. The cap being low this year would have made them harder to keep, I believe, but feel free to prove me wrong on that one.
I'm thinking next year, some long term spending happens.
Van Noy was curious, but glad to see Phillips making him forgettable.
Karras was a one year guy to bridge for Dieter; now, we have to see if Dieter can hammer down the spot.
I think a lot of those 2020 FA's were "sign because we had to fill cap space" guys, with no long term intentions. The cap being low this year would have made them harder to keep, I believe, but feel free to prove me wrong on that one.
I'm thinking next year, some long term spending happens.
There was a meeting after we went 1-7, the defense players asked for a meeting with the DC/HC and got their complaints out, all of a sudden, the scheme changed, play-calling changed drastically, and they're back to their 2020 form.
Phillips is sure lovin' it.