If I was GM for the day, I would draft Miami's QB (Tannehill or Weeden). I would not sign Manning or Flynn: Manning because he's just a short term fix and Flynn is a legend in his own mind.
As another poster stated, how much did any of Manning's previous backups learn while he was the QB? Manning was the offensive coach not the folks actually hired to do the job, so than when Manning went down, there went the offense. The same would happen here, if Manning was to get hurt, how effective would the backup be? Would I be unhappy if Miami went to the playoffs under Manning, no. I would be very happy, but than what. I am looking more long term than short term. We live in a society of instant gratification and that is all Manning would provide.
has anyone considered the fact that brady and bilicleck (however u spell his name),has owned manning his whole career,even in his prime.
yeah but when the both of their careers are over,i think brady will always be looked at as the greatest because he always beat manning when it counted.maybe that's why manning is afraid to come to miami.he did..but the tides kind of turned. The pats used to own the colts during the first few years and in the playoff games, but the last few years the colts have won against the pats. So im not so sure, how about that come back win like in 2010 that the colts won 35-34? and bill had the pats go for it, because he wanted his pats to finish the game and was nervous about peyton having the ball ad driving it down scoring on his defense.