MelbournePhin
Active Roster
was watching ESPN last night. He is supposedly the 5th best RB prospect according to mel. Does anybody know more about this guy? If we were to trade down in rd 1, would he be worth a late 1st rounder?
McClendon is too slow and not elusive. He'll be a short yardage back in the NFLAwsi Dooger said:I attended the game and frankly thought we would stuff him. But in the first half he probably put up 100 yards or close, one impressive run after another. Excellent vision and instincts and toughness and moxie. It would be 3rd and 10 and La Tech would hand to Moats and he'd improvise a first down. Everyone in the stands around me was amazed.
But he's still a change of pace back in the NFL. I don't like to pay a high pick for someone who can't go fulltime. Marion Barber and T.A. McClendon have a chance to be special backs, IMO. I prefer either of them to Moats, although McClendon may be drafted lower.
KB21 said:Moats is rising in the draft because Morency and Fason failed to establish themselves in their workouts.
Right now, the first five backs off the board will probably be the big three, JJ Arrington, and Ryan Moats. Kay Jay Harris may have passed Fason and Morency on many boards.
The interesting thing is that Miami has shown a great deal of interest in both Fason and Morency, and it is looking very likely that one or both may drop to their pick in the third round. This could add fuel to the fire of drafting Alex Smith in the first round.
never saw him play, i dont knowMelbournePhin said:was watching ESPN last night. He is supposedly the 5th best RB prospect according to mel. Does anybody know more about this guy? If we were to trade down in rd 1, would he be worth a late 1st rounder?
Boomer said:Moats has serious fumbling problems. He's also small and whilst stronger than JJ Arrington, he coughs the ball up way too much for my liking.
I agree that Fason and Morency have slipped to the top of 3. I would think that Fason would be better suited when mixed with what we have and how much better he could become.
And no matter what Mike Nolan says, the 49ers have Alex Smith higher rated.
I would suggest the top 8 might go a little like this with no trades:
1 - 49ers - Alex Smith
2 - Miami - Braylon Edwards
3 - Cleveland - Aaron Rodgers
4 - Chicago - Ronnie Brown
5 - Tampa - Carnell Williams
6 - Tennessee - Antrel Rolle
7 - Minnesota - Mike Williams
8 - Arizona - Cedric Benson.
Tampa could well deal Chris Simms to Cleveland on draft day and if the 9ers DON'T take Smith, look for Tampa to take a VERY STRONG interest at 5.