One Thing I Don't Understand!

[Jnaledu3]

CK,

Would you rank him your 4th QB ahead of Croyle, WHitehurst, and Jacobs? He had a very average year with his stats which unfortunately is all I ahve to grade him on at the moment. I did not get to see him play this year but was he not playing hurt for part of it? I know he's a good runner but what about his accuracy and arm strength, are they good? Just a few questions about him.

Reggie Mcneil the 4th best QB? :sidelol:

I have him as the 8th best behind Daryl Hackney.

 

[Canadi-Phin]

Reggie Mcneil the 4th best QB? :sidelol:

I have him as the 8th best behind Daryl Hackney.

Agreed, not sure how good he was, Just asking a question. CK send he's rising to the 2nd round. Hackey is too short and isn't a QB in the NFL. He shouldn't even be 7th on your list.

 

[General Tso]

Reggie McNeal's stock is rising. I'd be willing to make him a 2nd round pick at this point.

Wow... that's a high ranking for someone whose accuracy has been terribly inconsistent for 3 years. I don't like QBs with low completion percentages, especially against mediocre Big 12 secondaries (remembering that McNeal didn't play against UT this year). I don't see how anyone could rank McNeal ahead of Jacobs.