I strongly agree with the sentiment that if Joe Philbin had not kept Rishard Matthews in his doghouse for THREE YEARS because the guy had gone out to his car during halftime of a pre-season game (or whatever stupid thing it was), Miami likely would have had a good wide receiver on the field, may have been able to make a more productive draft selection in the 1st round of 2015, and also may have been able to retain Matthews by not pissing him off.
In hindsight, I dislike Joe Philbin more than I did when he was here. Some of the personnel moves the Dolphins made during his time in Miami were reasonable -- like trading Vontae Davis because he kept showing up for practice drunk -- while some of them were really infuriating. I think I blame Ireland for Dansby though, to be fair. Dansby took a shot at Ireland on the radio and that was that.
Matthews was not a good player during those three years. He played a fair amount and he was not good. When he changed the way he prepared and became a good player he played a lot more.
He was a 7th round pick that was undisciplined (which is one of the reasons he dropped to the 7th round), then he matured and became one of the better receivers in the league by his 4th year. You can choose to look at that as stupid Philbin keeping a great player on the bench the whole time or you can look at it as a developed player, a success story.
Here are our yards per play numbers:
2015
Landry- 1.30 yards per snap
Matthews- 1.27
Parker- 0.89
Stills- 0.78
Jennings- 0.50
2014
Landry-1.11 yards per snap
Wallace- 1.05
Matthews- 0.64
Gibson- 0.59
Hartline- 0.58
Sims- 0.56
(Stills-1.51 yards on each of his 617 offensive snaps in 2014. Which is better by far than any Dolphin receiver.)
2013
Gibson- 1.41 yards per snap on 252 snaps
Hartline- 1.12 yards per on 907 offensive snaps
Wallace- 0.98 yards per snap on 951 snaps
Matthews- 0.86 yards per on 519 snaps
2012
Hartline- 1.21
Bess- 1.05
Matthews- 0.65 (232 offensive snaps)
M. Moore- 0.59 (196 offensive snaps)
This doesn't seem that out of the ordinary to me. You could argue he took an extra season to develop but there was no reason to play him over the guys in front of him, at least not statistically. Hell, we're doing similar with Caroo and Grant now only they are playing way less than Matthews did and they weren't 7th round picks.