Ed -- the SEC homer ... .. let me ask you a question.
How many backs can you name that got more yardage from the LOS than Ricky Williams last season ??
The number is 4. In the entire NFL.
Can anyone say unreal expectations. My man Dan Marino would've KILLED for a top 5 RB. Hell, he would've killed for a top 15 RB!!!!
I know "RW is weird, RW is this, RW is that."
RW biggest problem was Ditka creating a monolithic task, and an ignorant O-Co in Mike MartzCarthy. He was weird and flaky, and though New Orleans claims to be an "eccentric" friendly place, the fan base, is for the most part from a very conservative background. They didn't like his weirdness, and he wasn't an ess-eee-cee guy, so there was no quarter for him. Like all temas there were good and bad fans, but not many that could ever except his quirkyness. While in Austin it was not only accepted but embraced. He seemed to do ok running the football back then.
So to post a reply about the fumbles, I'll go ahead and share with Phine Heaven what you've stirred up.
my quote from a previous post on the matter on whodatzone.com.
Ok --- Saints fans, let me ask you a question about the RW hatred.
[donning flame-res. suit]
So that I can get the general opinion straight ...
RW sucked, and we're all glad to be rid of him right ?? So, he fumbled A LOT, missed a LOT OF games with injury and was easy to tackle, couldn't break a long one, and was a generally weird dude. right ??
Let's see RW was all that, and still he did WHAT NO SAINT RB HAS EVER DONE !! 2 1000 yard seasons back-to-back. Oh, I know in this time of video games etc.. everyone thinks of 1000 yard season, as a simple goal, right ? Being a fan of the Dolphins gives me a great perspective on that, because though the Phins have had only had ONE losing season in my entire lifetime, we've also only had, what maybe 3 1000 yard backs ?? Maybe 4 ??
Here's some DATA to gnaw on RW haters ...
Even with the injuries, and the idiot playcalling of Danny A, then McCarthy. Even with the 4 game slide, and blah blah blah ... look at this and really mull it over ...
1043 yards per season
271 car.
364 yards rec.
44 rec.
1407 total yards per season.
Does anyone know what that is ??? It's RW average per season. Not giving him credit for per game, that's per season. Now before it gets thrown out there ... his fumbles. Even with the 3 in the one POS SF game, he was fumbling at a rate of once every 79 touches. (excluding the godfaresaken-game it's once every 105 touches.) If I have a guy that's going to get me 1400 yards (and that number will only rise in Turner's offense.) and to do that I give up a fumble every 100 + touches ... I'm not worried. Esp. when you look at his ypc after 20 + touches ...
This is for fumbles LOST, because like I said, you don't see fumbles for botched snaps, or a passes defensed stat. Fumbles that aren't lost are of little interest to me.
The stat is also misled by the 3 fumbles in the infamous EVERYONE QUIT NO v. SF game, and the two fumbles in the first season, while playing as the one armed man ...
Ed calls me a UT homer, because I live in Austin, and follow the Horns (I get to a lot of the practices, and know a coach or two), though he also knows the Noles are my team. (sorry Cane fans...).
If you want to understand more in depth Ed's analysis of RW, and his general feelings on him, by all means go to
www.whodatzone.com/bb and use the search tab ... search for Ricky Williams --- by Ed, and you'll get to read through the history of his "personal" grudge with RW.
For him to call me biased in his post, while having some validity (I do love RW, and his running style) and for you to not understand Ed's biased in the other direction, would be unfair.
from Ed about RW and Saints RB's ...
Two RB's come to mind that I believe are better.
Dalton Hilliard and Reuben Mayes.
I'd say SEC homer alert, but it's fairly obvious. I'll admit that both backs were good, and under-rated, because they played for the Saints, but neither were in RW class.
Here's the thread link. Notice Saints fans (many of the same who now talk about how much he sucks, and how glad they are to be rid of him ...) were talking contract extension, and only Ed had negative things to say. (this post was made after RW eclipsed 1000 for the second year in a row, and was the FIRST SAINT back to ever do it.