Thoughts On This Play By Tua - Is The Commentator Right? | Page 17 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Thoughts On This Play By Tua - Is The Commentator Right?

Can someone post the actual all-22 video of the play instead of still shots?
I’m not tech savvy enough to do that so if someone wants to walk me thru how to do it, or I can give someone my login if they want to put it together.
 
Big year for Tua


Another major concern within the Dolphins organization is the status of starting quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. If he suffers another injury this season, a rebuild could be on the horizon.

“Hate even saying it because nobody wants to see it, but another major injury for quarterback Tua Tagovailoa would likely ruin his career and send the Dolphins into a rebuild,” Bleacher Report’s Brad Gagnon wrote.

Tagovailoa is expected to be benched at some point during the season—whether due to injury or performance. While he has been the franchise’s quarterback since arriving in Miami, recent struggles and ongoing health concerns have shaken the team’s confidence in him. The Dolphins know the clock could be ticking on Tagovailoa’s time as their starter.

“What is interesting is that Miami may not have the same confidence they had in him two years ago. They could have created $19 million in cap room with a simple restructure, but opted not to do so, citing they didn't need the extra money,” Phin Phanatic’s Brian Miller wrote.


For now, Tagovailoa remains the starter—whether or not the belief in him is still strong. Once considered a prized young quarterback, he’s endured both injuries and inconsistency. This season feels like a pivotal one, with much left to prove.
 
If you can't admit to some of his great throws, you shouldn't nitpick all of the ones that aren't great. Difference in a couple yards on a ball 40 yards down field is something all quartbacks miss on.
biggest one off top of my head for me, game winner vs chargers 2 years ago.. inch perfect over the saftys shoulder right into the breadbasket .. was crazy, no other qb in nfl is making that throw
 
Big year for Tua


Another major concern within the Dolphins organization is the status of starting quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. If he suffers another injury this season, a rebuild could be on the horizon.

“Hate even saying it because nobody wants to see it, but another major injury for quarterback Tua Tagovailoa would likely ruin his career and send the Dolphins into a rebuild,” Bleacher Report’s Brad Gagnon wrote.

Tagovailoa is expected to be benched at some point during the season—whether due to injury or performance. While he has been the franchise’s quarterback since arriving in Miami, recent struggles and ongoing health concerns have shaken the team’s confidence in him. The Dolphins know the clock could be ticking on Tagovailoa’s time as their starter.

“What is interesting is that Miami may not have the same confidence they had in him two years ago. They could have created $19 million in cap room with a simple restructure, but opted not to do so, citing they didn't need the extra money,” Phin Phanatic’s Brian Miller wrote.


For now, Tagovailoa remains the starter—whether or not the belief in him is still strong. Once considered a prized young quarterback, he’s endured both injuries and inconsistency. This season feels like a pivotal one, with much left to prove.
wow interesting this guy would come out and say he is expected to be benched for performance reasons. that seems a bit over the top. i guess all the milfs in miami will be eagerly anticipating the zach wilson show? :)
 
wow interesting this guy would come out and say he is expected to be benched for performance reasons. that seems a bit over the top. i guess all the milfs in miami will be eagerly anticipating the zach wilson show? :)
I think he meant injury issues would be the reason he’s on the bench. Only time he’s been benched for performance was the Flores days so highly doubt that would start in year 4 under McD.
 
I think he meant injury issues would be the reason he’s on the bench. Only time he’s been benched for performance was the Flores days so highly doubt that would start in year 4 under McD.
the way i read it, he was citing injury OR performance:

Tagovailoa is expected to be benched at some point during the seasonwhether due to injury or performance.

“Those types of performances won’t cut it if the Dolphins are going to get back into the playoffs for the third time in four years with Tagovailoa at the helm,” Kay wrote.

If that happens, the Dolphins would likely turn to one of their offseason additions: former Jets quarterback Zach Wilson or rookie Quinn Ewers. The former Texas standout could already have an edge.

“Ewers could follow in Brock Purdy’s footsteps by taking over for an injury-prone and underwhelming veteran after being a late-Day 3 pick,” Kay added.
 
the way i read it, he was citing injury OR performance:

Tagovailoa is expected to be benched at some point during the seasonwhether due to injury or performance.

“Those types of performances won’t cut it if the Dolphins are going to get back into the playoffs for the third time in four years with Tagovailoa at the helm,” Kay wrote.

If that happens, the Dolphins would likely turn to one of their offseason additions: former Jets quarterback Zach Wilson or rookie Quinn Ewers. The former Texas standout could already have an edge.

“Ewers could follow in Brock Purdy’s footsteps by taking over for an injury-prone and underwhelming veteran after being a late-Day 3 pick,” Kay added.
Fair enough, just don’t think he’s being realistic on Tua getting benched for performance with McD. I remember a few years ago McDaniel mentioning that he would want Tua to play thru a rough game or patch of season so doubt it happens under his watch.
 
I think he meant injury issues would be the reason he’s on the bench. Only time he’s been benched for performance was the Flores days so highly doubt that would start in year 4 under McD.
A bit about the "author" Hunter Cookston -

Hunter Cookston began his career as a sportswriter for the Marion Tribune, where he covered local high school football, basketball and baseball. His passion for sports started at the age of four when he played his first year of tee ball. Growing up in Tennessee, he developed a deep love for the Tennessee Volunteers and Atlanta Braves. Hunter is currently attending Tennessee Wesleyan University, where he is pursuing a BA in Sports Communications/Management.

We should definitely be concerned about what this guy has to say. Seriously, he played MF'ing tee ball guys. Don't get no better than that....
 
Honest question. I get you and the other guy who likes likes the bucs said you were going to be here in the offseason all the time to post and be in everyone faces. That’s cool you said it and done it.

What do you like about this team? The 70ss? Because we been a soft team that can’t win on the road in the playoffs forever. You don’t like tua or McDaniel. We had the most success as a franchise in 2022 and 2023 since WAnny was coach with Lamar smith.

What do you like? What keeps you a fan?
Please don’t say I insulted you. Cause I have not. You guys like yourself and the guy that kinda roots for the bucs and hoops scoops have taken shots at this team , qb , organization all off season.

News flash. We all want a Super Bowl. We all know this isn’t good enough. But your posts all just stir the pot. There is nothing but a post that is to point out a flaw with the coach or qb.

We get it. We agree with you. We are not good enough. What is your point.

thats why reason made it and you didn’t.
What he likes and what he gets off on his “I’m so much smarter than you” posts were he starts off acting neutral but anyone with half and brain and even Stevie Wonder can see where he is going with it.

Frankly it’s tiring and it’s insulting but the usual suspects fall for it, show up saying Tua sucks, OP then gleefully joins in and we have yet another 30 page Tua thread over a single pass that while still completed wasn’t perfect.

I’m pretty tired of his schtick now. He really needs to seek help for his Tua Derangement Syndrome, I’m not sure if he’s another one that Tua kicked sand into his eyes while he was at the beach.
 
Last edited:
i didn't say those things. and i find the whole premise of this commentary to be quite immature and childish. the op started with a simple question. i think we now have the answer. deal with it. your binkie made a poor throw. but somehow the world is

i didn't say those things. and i find the whole premise of this commentary to be quite immature and childish. the op started with a simple question. i think we now have the answer. deal with it. your binkie made a poor throw. but somehow the world is still spinning.

You loved to prove that wouldn’t you ? Get your name in the National Geographic.
 
Fair enough, just don’t think he’s being realistic on Tua getting benched for performance with McD. I remember a few years ago McDaniel mentioning that he would want Tua to play thru a rough game or patch of season so doubt it happens under his watch.
Oh I agree that was what I meant when I said the comments seem over the top
 
Back
Top Bottom