Thoughts On This Play By Tua - Is The Commentator Right? | Page 18 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Thoughts On This Play By Tua - Is The Commentator Right?

What he likes and what he gets off on his “I’m so much smarter than you” posts were he starts off acting neutral but anyone with half and brain and even Stevie Wonder can see where he is going with it.

Frankly it’s tiring and it’s insulting but the usual suspects fall for it, show up saying Tua sucks, OP then gleefully joins in and we have yet another 30 page Tua thread over a single pass that while still completed wasn’t perfect.

I’m pretty tired of his schtick now. He really needs to seek help for his Tua Derangement Syndrome, I’m not sure if he’s another one that Tua kicked sand into his eyes while he was at the beach.
EXACTLY WHAT I SAID..

this guys irl single white female.. its legit unhinged.
and agreed with you, even before i started posting i saw one point where it was like a tua post everyday for a week, and everyone is under the guise of just asking opinions which everyone as you stated is an obvious attack YET again at tua, they will then ignore any proof/ views that contridict tua sucking, whilst preaching they were proved right.. well ofc if you only acknowledge opinions (with not facts or evidence) that support your dumb take.. ofc your gonna think your right.

its tiring, it adds nothing of value, and is never worth while opinions.. and tbh its gettin obnoxious
 
I don't have time to read through 18 pages of comments, so if this has been said already, so be it, but to me it looks like Tua put the ball exactly where he wanted it, perfectly between two defenders where only Hill could get it.

Tua's game deserves criticism for many reasons.....this play isn't one of them. Just some 'fan' with a grudge who doesn't understand what he is watching.

Of course, I wouldn't expect a guy saying the play should have given us 7 points instead of 6 to know what he is talking about.
 
biggest one off top of my head for me, game winner vs chargers 2 years ago.. inch perfect over the saftys shoulder right into the breadbasket .. was crazy, no other qb in nfl is making that throw

2:15 mark here



30 yard completion outside the numbers (a throw he apparently can’t make according to some) vs the Slay Jr on 3rd and 18. Lead to a key TD few plays later which kept Miami in the game right before until. Some awful calls in the 2nd killed this game but that eagles game was a very good game overall. He had a td called back on the 2nd drive due to an cotton holding I believe and tyreek also had a dropped pass where he would of walked in for another td.
 
I don't have time to read through 18 pages of comments, so if this has been said already, so be it, but to me it looks like Tua put the ball exactly where he wanted it, perfectly between two defenders where only Hill could get it.

Tua's game deserves criticism for many reasons.....this play isn't one of them. Just some 'fan' with a grudge who doesn't understand what he is watching.

Of course, I wouldn't expect a guy saying the play should have given us 7 points instead of 6 to know what he is talking about.
I don’t agree, I think he threw it off his back foot when he felt pressure and if he drove it in there the safety didn’t have time to recover. If you look at the first and 2nd still:

1749411612799.jpeg
1749411628171.jpeg

You will notice that Tyreek slowed up adjusting to the ball and still went from the 26 yard line in the first still to 16 yard line in the 2nd, meanwhile Hamlin has only covered about 5 yards because he was defending the seam and has to readjust his backpedal while Reek is running in a straight line…and this is with Reek slowing up, so if Tua drove it in there he wouldn’t have had time to recover. It’s even more obvious watching the all-22 live
 
Last edited:
2:15 mark here



30 yard completion outside the numbers (a throw he apparently can’t make according to some) vs the Slay Jr on 3rd and 18. Lead to a key TD few plays later which kept Miami in the game right before until. Some awful calls in the 2nd killed this game but that eagles game was a very good game overall. He had a td called back on the 2nd drive due to an cotton holding I believe and tyreek also had a dropped pass where he would of walked in for another td.

10 penalties assessed against the Phins, ZERO against the Birds
 
2:15 mark here



30 yard completion outside the numbers (a throw he apparently can’t make according to some) vs the Slay Jr on 3rd and 18. Lead to a key TD few plays later which kept Miami in the game right before until. Some awful calls in the 2nd killed this game but that eagles game was a very good game overall. He had a td called back on the 2nd drive due to a cotton holding I believe and tyreek also had a dropped pass where he would have walked in for another td.

Tua throws some absolute dimes and deserves credit for those throws. The specific throw in the OP however was underthrown and while you can’t call it a bad throw because we gained 30 yards on the play, it was a missed opportunity because a better throw where he plants and drives it in and Reek walks in for the score
 
2:15 mark here



30 yard completion outside the numbers (a throw he apparently can’t make according to some) vs the Slay Jr on 3rd and 18. Lead to a key TD few plays later which kept Miami in the game right before until. Some awful calls in the 2nd killed this game but that eagles game was a very good game overall. He had a td called back on the 2nd drive due to an cotton holding I believe and tyreek also had a dropped pass where he would of walked in for another td.

BEAUTY.. yeh that game was painful to watch, the roughin pass call for there first td was a joke, the rrefing in that game was so rigged it hurt to watch.

thing is, the throw in it self didnt seem that weak armed to me either, he rockets that one
 
I don't have time to read through 18 pages of comments, so if this has been said already, so be it, but to me it looks like Tua put the ball exactly where he wanted it, perfectly between two defenders where only Hill could get it.

Tua's game deserves criticism for many reasons.....this play isn't one of them. Just some 'fan' with a grudge who doesn't understand what he is watching.

Of course, I wouldn't expect a guy saying the play should have given us 7 points instead of 6 to know what he is talking about.
yeh, like theres tua throwing the ball further then that with little effort.. so i don't think its a case of he cannot throw further, its clear to me right or wrong, he saw the safety coming across so put the ball where he knew hill would get it and not make a risky play.

could he have gone further /lead hill for a td, its all speculation, he could of over thrown for an int, hill coulda dropped it, hill coulda tripped over, the safety could of grown a rocket booster in his butthole and flew up in the sky and grabbed it.. its complete nonsense to claim had the ball gone further down field its a td, its just looking to hate on Tua for the sake of hating with no substance behind the claim as to why its a bad throw
 
Tua throws some absolute dimes and deserves credit for those throws. The specific throw in the OP however was underthrown and while you can’t call it a bad throw because we gained 30 yards on the play, it was a missed opportunity because a better throw where he plants and drives it in and Reek walks in for the score
again, you cannot prove if he does or doesnt.. its pure speculation .. neither you or I or tua or hill or anyone in this thread can know what happens if things play out differently.

cause helll I have seen hill drop easier passes then this one to squander tds, and again you have no idea if the safety makes it across or not/ what decision he makes if the balls further down field, claiming it is a td for sure is impossible
 
yeh, like theres tua throwing the ball further then that with little effort.. so i don't think its a case of he cannot throw further, its clear to me right or wrong, he saw the safety coming across so put the ball where he knew hill would get it and not make a risky play.

could he have gone further /lead hill for a td, its all speculation, he could of over thrown for an int, hill coulda dropped it, hill coulda tripped over, the safety could of grown a rocket booster in his butthole and flew up in the sky and grabbed it.. its complete nonsense to claim had the ball gone further down field its a td, its just looking to hate on Tua for the sake of hating with no substance behind the claim as to why its a bad throw
Watching the all-22 live I think if he throws it with better technique and drives it in then I don’t think Hamlin had enough time to recover. Dunno why you think that’s complete nonsense
 
again, you cannot prove if he does or doesnt.. its pure speculation .. neither you or I or tua or hill or anyone in this thread can know what happens if things play out differently.

cause helll I have seen hill drop easier passes then this one to squander tds, and again you have no idea if the safety makes it across or not/ what decision he makes if the balls further down field, claiming it is a td for sure is impossible
If Tyreek continues his route without having to slow down and actually catches the ball then I don’t see any angle Hamlin had to make a play on the ball, he just wouldn’t have been able to get there laterally and I thought the stills would clearly show that but I guess not
 
And I never said it was a bad throw, if he was trying to throw it to his back shoulder like that it’s a good throw but the better throw imo was just to lead him and drive it in and he walks in if the play plays out normally…Hamlin just didn’t have the angle

Don’t think you can call any 30 yard completion a bad throw given the result but I felt like TD was clear and open if he drove it in better.
 
And I never said it was a bad throw, if he was trying to throw it to his back shoulder like that it’s a good throw but the better throw imo was just to lead him and drive it in and he walks in if the play plays out normally…Hamlin just didn’t have the angle

Don’t think you can call any 30 yard completion a bad throw given the result but I felt like TD was clear and open if he drove it in better.
but how can you say he doesnt have the angle? on first one he does second one he also adjusts like hill to the ball placement.

like I know you didnt say its and throw,(tbf your one of ones on here i think has some of best objective unbiased takes,and your posts are a joy to read) im jsut sayin we cannot say this would be that if this happens,

to quote an old sayin (maybe very british)

if my aunty had a dick, she would be my uncle (not tryin to offend, hope you get the point)

aka its not that way, it is what it is and we cannot speculate as to what would of happened, we have no idea.. maybe you are right sure its a possibility but then maybe your not we don't and won't ever know, so to the original point of this whole topic that if he throws it further its a td, its a dumb arguement to make cause no one ahs any idea what events play out in that situation
 
Back
Top Bottom