Top 6 Reasons why Matt Flynn would be our best option at QB | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Top 6 Reasons why Matt Flynn would be our best option at QB

Kyndig

Seasoned Veteran
Super Donator
Club Member
Joined
May 12, 2006
Messages
4,986
Reaction score
7,378
Matt Flynn is our best option at QB and here are the reasons why

Now that we have our new head coach, I've been thinking about the QB position and what we can do to upgrade it. First of all, we will absolutely keep Matt Moore. He's proven that he is decent and he is cheap and regardless of whether we draft a rookie who can sit and learn from him, or get someone like Matt Flynn we will need a quality number 2, and he won't be much of a cap hit.

Before we get into the reasons why I think Matt Flynn won't end up being like another Kevin Kolb I'd like to say that I'd prefer Matt Flynn over Peyton Manning because I don't want another QB who is on the downside of his career with so many injury question marks, and it's unclear that Peyton would play anywhere else anyways. It was painful watching Marino's last couple of years as he was a shell of himself, looked like the Michelin man and had the mobility of a crippled snail, he was getting killed back there. I don't want to see that type of thing again.

Right, so here are the reasons why I like the idea of going after Matt Flynn:

1. Joe Philbin. He is no doubt intimately familiar with Matt Flynn's strengths and weaknesses and if we do end up signing him, it's because he believes in him and liked what he saw every day in the film room, the practice field, and on game day in the limited engagements that he played in.

2. Green Bay has a history of producing Quality QBs that have gone on to other places and succeeded. Kurt Warner (actually cut, but still, they saw enough in him to sign him), and Matt Hassleback. This is as opposed to Philadelphia (anyone remember AJ Feely?) and Kevin Kolb.

3. Aaron Rodgers. I mean, what did Kevin Kolb learn sitting behind Donovan McNabb and Michael Vick? Donovan McNabb was inconsistent, lazy, and not very accurate by all reports and Vick possesses physical tools that Kolb doesn't so he can't just try and imitate Vick. On the other hand, Matt Flynn was in the film room with Aaron friggin Rodgers. I'll bet he learned a ton from him, just like Aaron learned from Brett Favre and how did that turn out? From that Lions game I saw, that Green Bay offense in a high pressure situation didn't even skip a beat with Matt Flynn. He looked incredible. Poised, accurate, and in complete mastery of the same offense he could run down here.

4. Offensive system continuity. If he comes here he will be set up to continue his development in a system he has been in since 2008. I wouldn't underestimate the value of that.

5. Accuracy. Granted, it's limited action in the pros, but in 2010 he went 40 of 66 which is 60% accuracy in a pro system vs pro defenses. In 2011 he went 33 of 49 for 67% accuracy vs pro defenses with 6 TDs vs 2 ints and Vs the Lions, High Pressure game he went 31 of 44 for a 70.5% completion rate and 6 touchdowns. Kevin Kolb never ever did that nor anything close to it, I believe that this guy is the real deal and would be thrilled if we got him.

6. Cost. Forget financial cost because who cares? a. it's not your money, and b. Franchise QBs cost money so if you've got a good one he's going to cost you. So the cost that matters to me are draft picks and I'm betting Matt Flynn will cost less of those than if we trade up to position number 2 or 3 to try and land RGIII. That would allow us to draft BPA with our draft picks, I'd even be cool with a right tackle with our first pick in that scenario if that was the best player on the board.

7. Plays his best in big games. Named Offensive MVP of the BCS Championship Game after connecting on 19 of 27 passes for 174 yards and four scores, and his performance in that Lions game shows me the stage isn't too big for this guy.

These are the reasons why I think that Matt Flynn is not another Kevin Kolb and why I think we should aggressively pursue him. You can't predict these things, but I bet he's going to be great.
 
I like Flynn as competition for Matt Moore. Let them compete in training camp and may the best QB win the job.
I am against just handing Flynn the starters job. His resume as a starter is only a couple of games.
I believe that the Fins could be successful with either QB, but I want to see them battle it out in camp.
 
I hear you, but the money that they are going to have to pay Flynn to Land him means that he will probably be expected to enter camp as the starter.
 
I keep warming up to the idea of Flynn, but I don't think you can pay him starters money. Even starter money like Ryan Fitzpatrick or Kevin Kolb would be too much IMHO. At least Kolb had 7 or 8 starts before Arizona made that mistake. 2 NFL starts? I just don't think it is wise to make a starters financial commitment to him.
 
I hear you, but the money that they are going to have to pay Flynn to Land him means that he will probably be expected to enter camp as the starter.
So how will we know if Flynn is that much better than Moore if there's no competition. Do we take Philbins word and overpay a backup?
 
What it's about is how much competition there is for his services, in a market based system supply vs demand will determine how much money you will have to pay him regardless of what people like you or I think. Perhaps he won't cost that much money, but based on history, what we saw with Kevin Kolb who also had limited action that's not bloody likely and it will probably take big money to sign him. However, there are some things you can put in the contract to give yourself an out in case he doesn't pan out. In fact, i don't think it will cost Arizona much to get out of Kevin Kolb because the contract was front loaded, so they can get rid of him without taking a huge cap hit. Google it and you'll see what I'm talking about.
 
Perhaps they will compete, but at the end of the day if they are paying one guy $50 million (hypothetically) and the other guy significantly less than that, which QB do you think they will want to see start?
 
they have a history of backup QB's succeeding, favre was a backup, brunell, hasselbeck, rodgers, and now flynn
 
What about Flynn's 5 interceptions in those 2 games. I don't know about you, but that is a lot of picks. Green Bay also produced Brian Brohm.
 
I believe what Kyndig said in his post about "You're going to have to pay cause franchise QB's cost money" is right on. Flynn is first going to sign somewhere that he feels he's the leader for the starting job. Not that he can't lose it during training camp, and sure, that's a risk when you pay that kind of money, but, I firmly trust if Philbin believes him to be worth that kind of money, than he is. But we can't NOT pay him the money he's going to command if we want a "franchise QB". Which i'm not saying he is, but, trying cheap "stopgap" guys behind center has been part of our problem. We've been trying to use a band-aid on a gushing wound...again, if Philbin believes Flynn to be worth the $$, I trust his judgement and am all for finally investing in the position and saying, we believe you're our guy for hopefully the next decade..
 
they have a history of backup QB's succeeding, favre was a backup, brunell, hasselbeck, rodgers, and now flynn
I just don't believe Matt Flynn is the answer to our problems at Qb. If we do bring him in I hope it's an open competition.
 
He will get a salary that pays him in the 2nd tier of QBs and a nice signing bonus so you pay it instead of letting him walk away. If he is paid that money he is not competing for a starting job.

I think Joe Philbin can best determine the value on Flynn. It may be difficult to believe but he knows him a little better then any of us.
 
He will get a salary that pays him in the 2nd tier of QBs and a nice signing bonus so you pay it instead of letting him walk away. If he is paid that money he is not competing for a starting job.

I think Joe Philbin can best determine the value on Flynn. It may be difficult to believe but he knows him a little better then any of us.

You are basing that on what? You think Mike Shanahan isn't going to be interested in signing Flynn? Matthew Schaubb and Kevin Kolb both got big money to sign with a team as their starting Qb, both didn't have very many more starts than Flynn. Once again, not to beat a dead horse but the market will determine how much he will be paid and it will be alot because that's just the way it is. If you stack up Luck, RGIII and Flynn all next to each other based on their body of work there is no reason to think that Flynn doesn't have as good of a chance as any of them to become a successful NFL QB and they will all be paid that way based on thei respective positions I.e. draft vs free agency. Just watch and see
 
Back
Top Bottom