Orange Fin Bad
Active Roster
This is nail on the head. Perfectly stated.The problem isn’t that the guy can’t throw the ball 50 or 60 yards. I’m sure he can. The problem is against NFL DBs he can’t throw the ball that far in the super tight windows bc NFL DBs break on the ball a lot faster than in college.
No offense to those who keep saying well I saw him throw deep in college (especially no disrespect meant to SF) but y’all go watch Bryce Young for Bama this year. Go watch Mac Jones last year. Watch Jalen Hurts at Bama. EVERY Bama QB throws deep balls and hits them. That’s not something that just Tua himself was doing. Every Bama QB since Saban embraced the spread throws deep balls and completes tons of them. It’s easy to do when you out talent every single team you play.
Tua as well as the coaching staff and every team we play KNOWS he either can’t or won’t throw that opposite hash deep out route or that deep in pattern in the middle of the field or those deep seam routes down the middle of the field.
The guy can throw the football. He just can’t throw it with zip or at least enough zip to make those throws on patterns from the wide hash or really any throw that requires zip to beat NFL DBs that break on routes and jump them. Once again I’ll say it he’s limited. Certain things he can do well not elite. But he’s a top 5 pick. Why should we lower the standard for a guy selected that high? I just don’t understand why everyone wants to lower their standards.
The biggest thing for me is if he were on any other team and we were playing that team everybody here would be chalking it up as an automatic win and I can only imagine the things people here would say about how bad he is.
For Christ sakes we have people here that actually put down and bash Justin Herbert but will defend Tua with everything they got. If any fans of other teams were to read some of this we see on here daily at how people defend Tua they would laugh so hard they’d pass out. We play Houston this week... go read their board about the game and look at the things they say about Tua. Go read the things Buffalo fans say about him or NE or he’ll even the Jets. When we play Baltimore go read their board. It’s every other teams fans that all think the same thing about Tua and that’s that he’s no good.
And I’m sure the usual suspects will jump in here and say who the hell cares what other fans think and I’m not saying I do. I’m simply saying how can it be possible that everybody else thinks he’s no good and we’re the only ones that think he is? Are people really going to try and tell me that our little slice of the pie in our fan base is right while the other 31 teams fan bases combined are all wrong?
As for the part in bold, bro, I am a phins fan and I laugh so hard I pass out sometimes when reading this stuff from Tua apologists. Think about it. These guys come on here and belittle other posters with words and labels such as "QBWinz," "Average fans," and more. Never mind the fact that up until this season they apologized for Tua by touting his record in games he started. Also, never mind that some of those games were won thanks to Fitzpatrick coming in at the end after Tua stunk the joint up. Now, one who points out Tua's record is a "QBWinz guy" who doesn't know football. It is beyond hysterical watching these clowns sniff their own farts and pretend to be superior football fans who possess deep knowledge of the game while not even realizing that Tua absolutely sucks. These are the same people who are on here criticizing Tom Brady's arm strength and comparing him to Tua. These people obviously have no clue what is transpiring on the football field. It is beyond hilarious.
Tua is a bust. Full stop. He is at best a backup QB. He isn't a backup you would want to turn to for a full season either. He's a guy you could try and get by a month or so starting if your good QB gets injured. If you have to count on Tua for a full season, your season is over.