Said this before but comparisons between Tua and Josh Allen as rookies is totally bogus. Allen was widely viewed as a “raw” talent lacking refinement BUT with an immense upside based on his cannon arm, superior athletics and overall size / composition. The kid was the quintessential example of a “project” and not some legit NFL ready player. It was all about the kid’s potential. Very much boom or bust.
Tua on the other hand was advertised as a far more refined QB with more developed skills and accuracy – a player with the core capabilities to come to the NFL and be productive. He was never seen as a “project.” Beyond that no one was touting Tua based on his yet to be realized upside linked to his dominant athletics like Allen.
Come on BNF, you're better than this.
You also have to admit that even assuming he actually was NFL ready before the injury (and who knows how long he was going to need to adjust to the speed and sophistication of the pro game), the injury recovery, no pre-season, and a room full of very unimpressive "players" at the skill positions didn't make an already hard job significantly harder. Like it or not, Tua is a system QB, and he's never going to light the world up with highlight play after highlight play. Assuming who he was in college translates to the NFL, he's going to grind you down with precision and timing with few mistakes. Montana made a pretty good run that way, and if anything, the rules have evolved to be even more friendly to that kind of game.
Would it be better to have a QB that *IS* the system like Marino, of course. Unfortunately, they are truly generational (20+/- years or so, not just "wow, did you see that play on ESPN"). Not to mention, for some reason, all of those "obvious" truly physical marvels, for some reason keep slipping down the draft and past 20+ teams at a time. Maybe picking a good player isn't so obvious after all.
With Tua, while we shouldn't be happy about it, this is the first year we'll really get to see what he's about. A full year post recovery, a full off-season to be football ready, and hopefully some upgrades on the offensive side of the ball via new blood and growth from the existing players will, without excuses, show us what we drafted -- for better or worse.