The "Yeah but" arguments are irrelevant and it's all you fall back on when you have no other argument.
You cam find any situation to prove any QB isnt good or great under that scenario..
Doesn't make it a valid argument.
If recent success is the bar, then Tua shredded the cold weather argument last year.
Since Tua doesn't have playoff experience, we can utilize his college career to project. That includes a championship.
Nothing to do with objective lenses.
I don't recall 1 analyst expert etc.... criticizing Justin Herbert prior to last years playoffs because he didn't have playoff experience.
It's simple. He was anointed, so the argument or debate doesn't get used.
If the argument is selective, depending on the athlete, it's not a valid argument to criticize.
IMO of course